I watched the 2000 GF last night, and marvelled at the strength, skill and toughness of our Team.
I have tried to do a player comparison but it is tough, as 2000 had so many Champions. Can man for man, the current squad reach these heights ? Interested to here your views
I kinda think we need to let go of 2000 a bit. It’s a supremely underachieving side that should have had a 3 peat. All these comparisons do nothing except build up the boys to fail. Like ch7s coverage of the Olympics.
2000 was the most dominant season by a team I’ve ever seen. I see more 1993 in this group than 2000, and really if you look at the last 2 premiers, they were unfancied teams that played their best football at the right time of the year and weren’t necessarily the best team throughout the course of their premiership years. We are in a group of about 6-8 clubs who would be thinking they can make a run at it if they stay healthy and play their best footy come finals. 2000? As much as I’d love it, I don’t see any club in the AFL right now looking that far superior to the rest…
Except if you look at the squad from 1998 and see how they developed with experience and belief, I think you can consider the current squad in the same way.
Watching the GF replay and games from that year, while we had skill and talent in the forward line, it was the midfield toughness and domination that got the ball moving.
Who would you replace from the 2000 side with a 2018 player?
Hurley for Wallis
Merrett for Moorcroft
and then…
the 2000 side would slaughter the 2018 side. As for 1998 vs 2018, well let’s see what they do over the next 2 - 3 years. It’s there, as in being a premiership side, but they have a long way to go.
I’m not old enough to actively remember 2000, but there’s just no way the current side is as tough, fierce or ruthless, nor does it have as much class.
Also doesn’t leak goals at an alarming rate and much better defensively. No disrespect to the 2018 group, but it’d probably get beaten hands down
Let’s not forget that 2000 Premiership was bookended by 2 great eras.
The end of the NM one, and the start of Brisbane.
Those were 2 great sides and we needed some luck in order to win all 3.
Don’t lose Hird and Lucas in '99, and have Hird and Mercuri close to 100% fit in 2001 GF, then maybe we could have 3peated.
It’s a big call though, when you have genuine challengers.
I personally think the Hawks got lucky with their 3 in a row.