You’re being cute and all but I wonder if anyone has legitimately seen him play. Is he just awesome by virtue of being an unknown quantity? Sneaky edit was wise btw
There’s a bit to like about him, though of course, he is no plug/play savior, despite knee-jerkers.
He has a nice size, he thinks about disposal, quite agile, decent speed, decent kick - has a good skill level at most things. Not sure if he has a big weapon.
You’re not wrong, but it does speak to the quality of our backline. We had similar problems with good opposition entries in 2014 (more to do with lack of pressure than turnovers, but the results were the same), and our forward line was spectacularly dysfunctional. Our backline was a huge part of what made us a finals side. Hooker, Hurley, Hibberd, and Baguley was a fantastic group defensively.
If our current backline was a really good group, they wouldn’t have looked great last night because of the reasons you outlined. They looked bad because they’re not very good and they didn’t get the help they need.
So for mine we definitely need to fix the things up the field in the short term, but I would just as importantly be looking for ways to improve the personnel down back (which is a longer term proposition).
Out: JoeDan - send a message to Joe and the whole team. Stop looking for free kicks and kick the goals when you get the opportunity. Last night he was in a pack of players, faked a push in the back when he should have held his position and brought the ball to ground. Result was a end to end goal for Freo. Joe’s first 2 games have been rubbish.
Out: Tippa. Looks completely lost with no real role to play. He can play VFL while the coaches think about it.
In: Smaller forward line, running to the ball not away from it and manning up opposition players.
There’s no point dropping tippa or joe. Their form will change, although joe is utterly frustrating atm.
I honestly don’t see much change. Everyone was off. I’td be good to have a look at another kid Sooner rather than later IMO. I’d like to see Clarke get a run
Jeez it makes for a long week when you lose in such poor fashion.
Too one dimensional at either end. Begely out for Raz. Brown, who I think offers more than Hartley but has had a couple of shockers out for McNiece, if not fit or then Ridley or Redman or Bags.
Tippa has only turned up for 1/4 so far this year to be pushed up the ground or defence earlier. Daniher needs to be spending more time in the ruck. Both need help to find form.