Changes vs GWS (2020, round 10) - speculation

50:50 game!? No way. Just fell in against Adelaide says this team is cooked. It would be a miracle if they got within 4 goals even without Toby Green

We are a chance to surpsie and play a different brand after embarrassing loss.
McKenna forward is a good idea, but imagine he will still spend time in the back half too.
must give stewart another chance against old mob, even though he was poor.

In: McKernan, McKenna, Mosquito(ten goal loss last week Mosquito was promised) Hooker, Langford, Guelfi
Out: Bellchambers, Gleeson, Cahill, Zerk-Thatcher, Towner, Ham

Rush Hooker back in, he loves playing against the giants

B: Saad Hooker Hurley
Hb: Francis Ridley Redman
C: Cutler Parish Guelfi
Hf: McDonald-Tipungwuti McKernan McKenna
F; Mosquito Stewart Langford
R: Draper Shiel McGrath
Int: Merrett, Smith, Zaharakis, Snelling,

Emg: Zerk-Thatcher, Big Boi Begley, Phillips

*Guelfi in to tag whitfield. Ham managed

1 Like

Hooker’s injured.

Could make a quick recovery from calf, been 2 weeks already (and was only minor injury).
If he is out then Zerk has to stay in

31y/o KPD with history of soft tissue injuries returns from a calf after only two weeks eh?

I’ll have what you’re havin…

3 Likes

There is no match up for Hooker vs GWS anyway

They aren’t playing any really big kpf or fwd/ruck

Cameron, Himmelberg & Finlayson are far too mobile

could play on Finlayson

Zerk on Finlayson
Francis on Cameron
Hurley on Himmleberg

It’ll get really ugly this week. Whitfield, Williams, Kelly, Coniglio and Taranto all in good form. Their run and spread from stoppages is the scariest thought. Could be a huge belting.

2 Likes

Whitfield - Guelfi tag
Kelly - McGrath
Coniglio - Shiel
Taranto - Parish
Williams - Merrett

Draper give us first hands on it from the stoppage again, need mids perform better and hit some targets up forward.

Himmelberg is in pretty good form out of their big forwards.
Finlayson is lacking a bit of touch.
Zerk could be an option for him, but that’s mainly because I don’t want him taking the other two.

I’m not sure who put on Cameron.
If Ambrose was fit, it would almost certainly be him.
Hurley seems more suited to Himmelberg, and I’m not sure Francis can run with Cameron who is getting a long way up the ground.

Can anyone see us playing Ridley on Cameron.
The negative being he would be out of our defensive fifty regularly.
Just spit balling the match ups in my head.

Redman needs to go. Has been awful this year. Have zero confidence in him.

3 Likes

So thankful Toby Greene got injured. Would’ve been funny if Redman played on him, could’ve kicked 10.

1 Like

Francis is a great match up for Cameron imho (fitness permitting). He’s the only guy we’ve got who has a fraction of the explosiveness necessary to keep up with him on the lead.

Hurley to Himmleberg.

BZT to Finlayson.

I’m warming to the idea of McKenna forward also, for a few reasons:

  1. He couldn’t do any worse that our current mob and at best is a very scary potential matchup.
  2. As brilliant as he is his brain fades can cost us, and brain fades are generally better had a long way from opposition goals.
  3. While we would miss his run from defence, we also kind of need to move past him anyway. We just have to learn how to break through a press with out heroics from Saad and McKenna.
2 Likes

Yeah nah.
Cameron would blow him up.

5 Likes

Francis would be lucky to play this week given his effort last Friday. Let alone playing on the oppositions best forward (now that Greene is unavailable)

2 Likes

At least McKenna is fired up for the game this week.

Oh wait. No, it’s just Call of Duty :joy:

8 Likes

Im with you.
Gutted.
Guess as one of my only outlets to give me some external joy,its now compounding my sadness.

1 Like

I’m the same with McKenna, can’t hurt to try. I would actually start tippa on the half back flank in his place for the run, carry and ball use

Feel for Gleeson but he’s half the player he was pre ankle injury.

So Gleeson out, McKenna in.

Langford and McKernan also in, I’d do it for Zaka and t bell but no doubt it’ll be Cahill and someone else

1 Like

Agree tippa is the barometer, he needs to be involved early and is one of best uses of the ball. The coaches persist with starting him forward where he is staved of the ball…FFS, and then when it’s the third qtr and we are down by twenty, decide to make a move

1 Like

Another slaughter-fest coming up. Snakes and ladders sitting on 10th about to slide further down the slippery slide. Hope the draft picks are good this year.