Crichton Medal 2024

Leader board tells me that the coaches think 5 guys were doing all the work.

2 Likes

So why did they give Ben McKay so many votes?

“How many dudes do ya know roll like this? How many dudes ya know flow like this?”

Not many, if any!

2 Likes

Just saw the results.

Redman in the top 10? Surely that only because he played so many games. He was absolute trash this year

Well done to Zac. I so hope he see’s some type of success. He truly deserves it

1 Like

Because despite are few errant handballs he did a pretty good defending especially against the avalanche of ball the forwards and mids let through

6 Likes

The top 5 are rubbish?

He didn’t show ? So THAT’S why he didn’t get a gong…

Jones and Redman had very poor years. McGrath wasn’t top 4 at all. Stringer and Langford had good first half of the year but no one who missed out should be replacing these two anyway. McKay also definitely dropped away right towards the end but he was better than Kyle and Jake.

Really it is Zach, Nick, Sam and Jye, after that Ben McKay… rest were all dreadful.

That top 10 is a very sobering reflection of the list.

Fck me our list is sht.

2 Likes

For the so called game breaking gun ruckman in Draper not making that top ten says abit

1 Like

Yes but the dramatic reforms of the past two years have made us well placed for success…

Says to me he only played 13 games this season.

3 Likes

16 games cobber, and in that a player can get a max 40 votes per game and with jones finishing tenth on 80 points it isn’t very impressive at all

1 Like

No. The list is rubbish.

Oh how nice it would be to be wondering why the bloke who finished 15th wasn’t top ten because he’d had a great season?

Instead we’ve got players who made the top ten simply because there were that many slots to fill in the template.

We suck.

5 Likes

Billy likes to drink soda.

Miss Lippys car; is green!

4 Likes

So we just have a top 5 then

Harry jones finishing 10th is the biggest laugh of all time

6 Likes

Yeah i agree

Apart from McGrath the rest of the top 5 was fine

As long as we ■■■■ McGrath out of it.

Unless “kick height” is a valued team metric, in which case give him the Brownlow.

Did anyone else here stringer got up and left after barhams speech?