Discussion/Changes v GWS - SAT 9th May @ 4.15pm

Football Discussion Dustin Fletcher Hangar
21

Because the club is incompetent

11 Likes
22

Agree. Heā€™s a way off atm.

23

Gerryne isnā€™t the answer. Play Reid every week we possibly can.

1 Like
24

Letā€™s not throw good money after bad.

Setterfield shouldnā€™t have been given a list spot, let alone in the team with a generally fit list of mids. Would likely push someone like Sharp back to the forward line.

25

Iā€™d put him in for Caldwell.

1 Like
26

Theoretical - but I wouldnā€™t mind these changes..

OUT: Caldwell, SEH, Farrow, Kondo, Prior, Gresham, McKay
IN: Parish, Redman, Johnson, May, Setters, Stringer, Lav

Blaki Reid McGrath
Redman Lav Roberts
Langford Parish Duursma
Robey Caddy ADW
Stringer May Edwards

2MP Durham Merrett

Bench: Setters Sharp Nguyen Johnson Cox

Just watch the package carve us up this week and Lav to take 10 intercept marks down back..!!

Right now Iā€™d gladly swap McKay for Lav..

1 Like
27

changes

Out: Kondogiannis, El-Hawli (collar bone), Caldwell (managed), Gresham, Blakiston
In: Redman, May, Parish, Johnson, Tsatas

b: Prior McKay Roberts
hb: Redman Reid Farrow
c: Duursma McGrath Day-Wicks
hf: Robey Caddy Cox
f: Nguyen May Langford
r: Wright Durham Merrett
int: Sharp, Edwards, Parish, Johnson, Tsatas
Emg: Setterfield, Perkins, El-Achkar

  • McGrath to play on Greene.
  • Redman on Stringer
  • McKay on Hogan
  • Reid on Riccardi
  • Cox to relief ruck.

Looks like a tall immobile forward line. Huss kicked 3 goals maybe deserves to come in.

28

Does it really matter?

4 Likes
29

Broke - Kako and Gresham
Woke - Nguyen and Huss

:thinking::thinking::thinking:

1 Like
30

Because thatā€™s what Scott will do, not what I would do.

32

It would be great if we could trade Mckay out a get Lav back. Even if just for one game. At least he gives effort. I think we all understand that the list has holes everywhere but the lack of effort is the killer for supporters

1 Like
33

Iā€™m flying up to Syd for this game( got tickets at the start of the year) so hopefully they put on a better show.

My team would be.

McGrath Blakiston Farrow

Redman Reid Roberts

Day-Wicks Tsastas Langford

Merrett Caddy Robey

Nygun May Edwards

Wright Durham Parish

Sharp, Cox, duursma, Johnson, gresham

In. Redman, Tsastas, May, Johnson,Parish

Out. Caldwell,seh(inj) McKay ( inj) Prior,kongo

McGrath - Greene

Reid -hogan

Redman-stringer

Blakiston -cadman

2 Likes
34

Bryan was gassed 5 minutes into the 3rd quarter of the reserves game. No way he comes in. He is not fit enough.

35

Out: Saad,Blakiston,Cox
In: May,Redman,Bryan

36

Forfeit

2 Likes
37

Out- both injured- Caldwell, El-Hawli

In- Setters (best on in VFL)

Redman (a class above in VFL and required backline leadership)

3 Likes
38

this is where weā€™re at in 2026 lol

1 Like
39

At least the game wonā€™t ruin motherā€™s day

3 Likes
40

Well I think we will better on Saturday. The giants form isnā€™t exactly scintillating.

Looking forward to a competitive hitout.

41

Absolutely no Setterfield under any circumstances