No one is mentioning Hunter.
I thought the list decision was between Voss or Hunter…we went with the taller KPF…but he did his knee during the next pre-season.
Bit of bad luck in the end.
7 Likes
I’m all for wishing players well at other clubs, but actively cheering for them against us? Cmon, where are your loyalties here?
I imagine 90% want us to lose for a better pick. Maybe at best 10% think we can win.
Prefering Voss to kick a bag over Luke Jackson or Treacy isn’t such a bad thing.
Voss last 2 games
3 North
3 Suns
If Voss keeps up this form, might need to change the thread name.
1 Like
cue “Brads an idiot for letting him go” etc,etc comments.
He’s average as fark only reason he kicks a bag is because we have no backline.
Jye Menzie kicked 4 once…
3 Likes
Vossy wouldn’t waste a bag by kicking it
4 Likes
Nino is right though. He’ll be on an undersized opponent or one that wouldn’t be in our team if we didn’t have injury issues. Kicking goals against us is only going to appease those with hate boners on brad. I’d rather see Blakiston give him a bath and gain confidence because he was pantsed by Geelong
4 Likes
A 200cm winger. Where does Brad sign up?
1 Like
Have you seen our midfield? We could certainly use someone who is a very good kick
Or you could play Mass at half back instead of a guy like Redman
1 Like
Why is it that every time we play a team with one of our cast offs, people feel the need to rehash all the same tired arguments that have played out ad nauseam since each player left/was shown the door?
They’re gone…they’re not coming back…
FFS people…move on.
7 Likes
Because it’s relevant to the discussion of whether Scott is a good judge of talent and good at development
3 Likes
Just like it was relevant each and every other time.
There’s nothing new in anybody’s argument (for either side of the coin) so it’s all just a rehash fo previous arguments.
you don’t win internet debating points with that attitude buddy
8 Likes
Have you seen Redman play??
Average kick
Poor defender
Soft
Where is the Jones option?
Asking on behalf of a B Scott.
Going back a bit but Steven Milne was a handy small forward.
1 Like
Remember watching him play in the reserves GF for us. Sheedy was keen to draft him but Saints swooped
Didn’t help that most of the essendon team didn’t like him
Well he was called tip rat for reason haha