Former #40 Tex Wanganeen

Yes. And?

So you managed to find a quote of Sheedy saying he was worried about the kid getting injured.
That’s great, except it doesn’t demonstrate that he was ACTUALLY fragile. If you can find them, there were frequent quotes from all and sundry suggesting he needed to change the way he played so that he wouldn’t get hurt. Except he didn’t, and he didn’t.

The fact that he would continuously take marks backing back in front of leading full forwards, week after week, and not get injured, shows your comment couldn’t be further from the truth. He was nick named rubber man for a reason.

I’d keep Wanganeen over Baldwin.

Why???

3 Likes

Because Tex has some AFL physical attributes, but has been unlucky with injuries. I don’t think Baldwin has the physical attributes required for AFL players. Not tall enough or athletic enough to make up for his lack of height.

Been saying it for 2 years. The fact he’s injury prone just makes it a more obvious delisting.

Even in the Tex Wanganeen thread, Clone Hirdy manages to gives Baldwin a clip.

4 Likes

I was asked. I just followed on from a previous discussion.

If it makes you feel better, I’d keep Baldwin over Tsatas.

It does a little

2 Likes

I love ya work a majority of a time but no way would you chop Tsatas before Baldwin

1 Like

what is it about a wanganeen that you peanuts don’t understand

I know Wanganeen has had foot injuries but I just don’t think he works hard enough to get fit.
Good, dedicated players find a way to be fit even when they’ve had injuries.
He’s played 11 games straight this season but to my eye it still looks like his biggest problem is not being able to run at the required standard.
I’d love to see how his GPS numbers compare to other players

True. Forgot that.

https://x.com/vfl/status/1817431605079880154?s=46

18 Likes

Geez I hope he doesn’t get the chop. Is clean with the ball, can kick,smart head.

Poor kid just needs a pre season he’s never had

15 Likes

New Rookie rules announced today mean Tex can stay on the rookie list for another year (does not need to be upgraded) which means he might get another lifeline if they club is 50/50 about him

32 Likes

If we can keep him as a rookie for another year we should.

7 Likes

Get him in, probably got more class and ability than half of these vanilla plodders.

3 Likes

He is finished

1 Like

He is not fit enough or strong enough to play AFL………he’s too far behind in physical development

2 Likes

Yeah nah

1 Like

Wanganeen isn’t AFL level