Gather Round Dub 2025 - Review Thread

You couldn’t possibly convince me that either of Port or Melbourne were anywhere near the top of their game in either game.

Sorry. The truth does hurt.

1 Like

To the eye, we’re about as good/bad as I expected in order to finish around 14th-15th. Somehow Port and Melb have started off the year like cellar-dwellers even more than we have. I expect Port will eventually pick up some wins but the Dees I’m far less sure about.

That Crows performance still concerns me as we couldn’t find a way to stem the bleeding for 4 whole quarters. The Pies game will be interesting considering their form and might show where we are at. I’m a bit worried we find ourselves in a similar position to the one we did last year, where our ladder position is too high too early and we keep dumping games into Shiel and Setterfield because they don’t deserve to be dropped.

1 Like

I didn’t watch the game live.

I watched the replay with a neutral lense, knowing that we had won.

Melbourne are absolute dogsh*t. There is no chance that a half decent team gives us this much space to take uncontested marks all over the ground.

The unwritten rule on this forum that ‘nobody is allowed to be negative’ after a win, is simply pea hearted crap. It’s called critique.

We punished Melbourne for it, so it’s a credit to us. But honestly Melbourne horrible.

1 Like

What about Geelong last week?

Did they magically turn their club around this week to beat the Crows after also beating the Dees by 39?

Yep. Spot on.

Are Geelong or Brisbane allowing us 3-4 minutes in the last quarter (when game was on the line) to play kick to kick with zero pressure?

Make no mistake… RAPT to win. And pretty surprised. But maybe wait a minute before lining up for finals tickets.

I used to compare our margins against other teams margins too.

In Grade 5.

You’re smarter than that.

1 Like

Squiggle knows sweet ■■■■!

In fairness, I was lining up this morning and I can confirm there was no one else around.

1 Like

Plus some of the prospects coming through our academy and a decent draft hand this year as well.

I’m in the virtual queue

1 Like

We could beat Pies on Anzac Day and some will still find an excuse on why Essendon won they will say that Pies had an off day and were rubbish

3 Likes

Never!

Squiggle is interesting as they display the S10 which is the mean prediction from the top 10 most accurate models from last season - the overall aggregate favoured us

It’s just 4 points. Who cares.

Show me where the Premiership is coming from? I’m done with being mediocre.

Be a top 4 side, or a bottom 4 side……. FFS Stop being middle of the road.

1 Like

Mckay threw his weight around and put a great bump had another solid game I’m happy for him keep it up Ben and shut those haters up who bronxed cheered :+1:

6 Likes

But we are a bottom 4 side nothing wrong with giving praise or credit when the team plays well and wins.

We are not going to Finish bottom 4.

2 Likes

Bookmarking this for future reference.

It’s because he’s a show off.

They probably won’t even be around in our next premiership cycle anyway.