If you put “that the pleb can play” as a caveat, then that might be true
Although I have managed to play two of the big sandbelts so far. I think YY is my personal favourite, having seen Royal but having not played it (President’s Cup).
I’ve put a nice little list together with the public access top 100 though… I think I’m up to 11 now.
I’ve played most of that list (although not all recently). RM is insanely good. The only course where I felt like I’d played out of my mind and still ended up getting completely smashed (I can’t putt, so thay was a major component, I’d nail a drive and an approach to 15ft and walk off with a double). There are just places where you stand over the ball and could think of 100 ways to approach a shot and you aren’t comfortable with any of them.
KH is generally the second “highest rated” and is heaps of fun, but is also a course that I always score well on. I’m not sure it’s better than the next group. Vic, Metro, Comm, Yarra are all fantastic tracks (Comm is mid major upgrade at the moment, but has some wonderful holes). I haven’t played Huntingdale for years, but apparently it has been subject to big changes. Woodlands I have a personal hatred of, only because i have always scored poorly there. Spring Valley I’ve only walked
(And yes, I have been very lucky to have been able to play all of these over the years. Growing up at that end of the earth with a golf obsessed father certainly helped)
Comm in 2002 would have been a day by day proposition condition wise, and I think that was just post that Cashmore work which was horrible.
They’ve gone a complete rebuild (overseen by Tom Doak) and regrass (finally going full Santa Ana couch fairways and going the same grass as Vic on the greens) which is currently halfway done as far as I know. I reckon in a couple of years it will be awesome. 16 could be the best par 4 in Melbourne.
I haven’t played Yarra post changes, but have driven past and done a triple take. One of my best friends was a member there for years and I’d played there a bunch in the old days. There have obviously been a million trees cleared out since then!
Yep. I wish I could just play consistent with all clubs in my bag. Last time I played, hit 6 greens with long irons which is unheard of for me. But my driving was shizen.