I honestly don’t think you can go wrong with either player.
It’s about what you value in a player really.
I’m all about McCluggage. As he’s just a natural footballer that does really freakish things and kicks goals out of nowhere. He Takes big risks with trying to hit targets through the corridor, breaks the lines and is a very good decision maker with choosing who to give the ball to. His strength is lowering the eyes and hitting the leading forward, but will have a shot if there isn’t a good option. He breaks away from congestion similar to a Judd/ Dangerfield.
McGrath will definitely be a ‘meters gained’ type player. Moves the ball quickly and kicks long down the line to try and break up the zone. In congestion he’s more likely to give off the hand ball, then push forward. As opposed to busting through congestion like McCluggage does. He drops off his opponent and takes intercepting marks and then looks to rebound with pace.
Can’t go wrong with either imo.