The win last night was great. We started poorly, but from the time the rain came to the very end of the game the team played with an intensity they haven’t displayed all year. We beat Collingwood to the ball; we outnumbered them at the contest; when they had the ball we forced turnovers through constant pressure and tackling. The number of times a Collingwood attack was stopped when pressure culminated with a Collingwood player tackled by two of our players was outstanding. And when one of our players got the ball he had teammates all around providing support and multiple options for an effective disposal. We deserved to win and we won well.
So what’s the problem?
The problem is that it was the first time this year that we’ve seen that, and in our heart of hearts we all know that the chances that we’ll see it again next week are about 20% at best. What’s likely is that we’ll see flashes of it; we might well dominate for 10 or 15 minutes or even a whole quarter; but it will either only come late in the game when we’re too far behind to catch up, or it will fizzle out after a bad umpiring decision or an easy set shot at goal is missed so we end up with a narrow loss. Or we may do just enough to win, as we did in the first two games: poor performances, but just not quite as poor as our opposition’s. And then of course we may just not turn up to play at all and get belted.
This has been our problem for a decade or more. We’ve played some great games and some inspired football, but always, just when we are beginning to hope that we might actually be on the road to success – i.e., a successful shot at winning the premiership – it’s snuffed out by a reversion to the slack, reactive, negative Essington football that we know so well, and the season ends with us either just falling into the eight or just falling short of it.
What I don’t understand is why. John Worsfold is an intelligent man; he captained West Coast to two premierships and coached them to one; he knows what it takes to win a flag. Ben Rutten hasn’t played in an AFL premiership or coached a premiership team, but he’s seen from close up what Richmond did. Blake Caracella certainly knows premierships as a player at two clubs and as an assistant at Richmond and Collingwood under a whole variety of coaches. We have plenty of money. We have excellent facilities. What we don’t have is consistent intensity.
I’m sick of it.