For 21 add Bill Busbridge
Champion of Essendon #14; ahead of Barry Davis, Harvs, Bomber Thompson, Long.
Champion of the colony (best player in Victoria) 1908, 1909.
#3 and #11, and #24 in the “champions of Essendon” - and that’s not including a 150 gamer, and a 250 gamer.
I think you’re off base. Cast your mind back to the shitfight when Hird gave it to Stanton, compared to the uproar when A Lee got 32 or S Gumbleron got 3. No comparison. From the start of Sheedy’s tenure, it’s the most famous number. Only 4 comes close, and that’s had about twice as many occupants over the same timeframe.