I’m not sure who’s in this car but WSPHU
12 Likes
It’s like parenting my two children.
One week one is an angel, the other is a punk.
Next week, punk turns the corner, the other one decides she’s the devil.
Good times.
Depends on what you could get for him. I assume not a lot, so yeah, I’d probably agree with you.
Supporters have very short memories. The amount of players that have played a few good early games at Essendon and then done very little after that is as long as my arm. McMahon is a very nice kick, but if you are only getting the ball 4-5 times a game, you’re not really contributing enough. He is not 18, he is 23. May has a few more AFL attributes, but will need at least 3 more years before we know if he is the answer.
I said it 2 years ago that we need to go after a KPF in the top end of the draft. I showed stats of where all the best forwards were drafted, 90% were first round picks. Now to be honest, there haven’t been too many available, which is why North keep selecting mids. Darcy, Walter and Thilthorp were either unavailable or at the very top end of the draft, so we had no opportunity there. Caddy is more of a mid sized forward that can play taller. Coincidently Brisbane and Geelong found Morris pick 31 and Neale pick 33, which comes to show there is talent outside of the first round, you just need to be able to identify it.
6 Likes
Fully integrated into the Essignton ethos.
1 Like
150 games for the big fella tonight. Let’s get around him.
7 Likes
1.5CG2MP
2 Likes
Unpopular opinion perhaps but I think he has had a really decent year. I think he’s goal kicking yips have coincided with more ruck time.
13 Likes
The real celebration will be when he gets to 203 games.
3 Likes
Haven’t finished top 4 in 25 years lol
He’s had. Good year and applied himself very well in tough circumstances
1 Like
Eyes open though 
2 Likes
Swap for JUH.
Easy switch when this ■■■■ can’t play for ■■■■.
And before anyone states some buttered up bull ■■■■, we dont have the luxury of other players…is Carlscum gonna swap for a Mckay or Curnow? So let’s get a better player who is a cheap option.
Or try another boot up the ass for this soft prick above.
I wouldn’t we look way better going forward with a smaller more mobile forwardline
Thought this was worth putting here.
That said, I Would be looking to trade him because I think he has value, and his age.
2 Likes
Yes. A key point is that the 3rd tall / backup ruck role is one of the least important roles in a team.
1 Like
they would be maybe three at max four i wouldnt trade this off season everyone else should be in the conversation to rebuild the list.
before I get asked the three are Caddy Roberts Durham
I wouldn’t trade Vigo…..rather go for a ride with him….
1 Like
I would keep him. Delivery into the forward line this year has been beyond abysmal. Even when the “first picks” were in.
1 Like