He needs to improve everything (except his kicking), not just his defensive contribution.
Heās scrawny, poor at contests, doesnāt read the play particularly well, and positions himself poorly, and defensively drops off way too many tackles.
Half back seems to be easier to read for him, and makes the most of his kicking. No chance at all to make it as a forward IMO.
I donāt think he will make it as a half back either based o what I have seen at VFL level.
You are afforded far more time and space on a wing at VFL level than you would be as a half back in the AFL and he just isnāt a good enough decision maker.
He would get caught far to often at AFL level in my opinion.
As a defensive forward you will be doing more chasing than being chased and I donāt think you need to be as spatially aware as you do as defender. Huge difference from being caught in your defensive 50 to being caught in the front 50.
No. But I think new rules allowing players who were delisted one year earlier to still count as DFAs come into effect. So anyone could add him to their senior list for free.