Carlton
Coach: Michael Voss
2025–
Points For – 14th
Points Against – 10th
Top 5 Best and Fairest
1 – George Hewett
2 – Jacob Weitering
3 – Adam Cerra
4 – Nick Haynes
5 – Patrick Cripps
2025 Rising Star Noms
Cooper Lord (Rnd 10)
Ashton Moir (Rnd 19)
Matt Carroll (Rnd 24)
Ins – Ben Ainsworth, Taylor Byrne, Campbell Chesser, Harry Dean, Ollie Florent, Will Hayward, Jack Ison, Liam Reidy
Outs – Charlie Curnow, TDK, Jack Silvagni, Ollie Hollands, Alex Cincotta, Jaxon Binns, Sam Docherty, Corey Durdin, Oraaaazio Fantasia, Will White
My Prediction
I am not sure I have ever been happier about being wrong. I thought this mob were a top 4 chance last year. There are very few teams that can match Essendon when it comes to mismanagement but Carlton would be right up there. They had the list to be a problem in the finals but just never got rolling.
The backline on paper looked sort of ok. I mean they have Weitering who despite threatening to derail his career, they have never managed to do it. Haynes was at times surprisingly effective last season but I don’t expect him to get better. Newman and Saad give them run, Newman can kick as well, Saad can kick but not always accurately. All in all it is a pretty average backline. They will miss Docherty off half back.
The midfield looks good on paper, Cripps is still a beast even if not as effective a beast as he was a few years ago. Hewett has been a very good pick up. Walsh is due another injury but if it doesn’t happen then he is very good. Throw in Hollands and Cerra and things look good. Jagga should be back early in the season as well and he unfortunately looks a super talented kid.
The forward line looks both better and worse than last year. Losing Curnow hurts but Florent and Hayward give them new avenues to goal. They just have to hope McKay keeps healthy both mentally and physically as they will need him to have a very good year. They have lost Motlop for the season and although a bit of a whipping boy, was also one of the few small forwards with pace. Still looks pretty average and with McKay getting the best defender every week, I don’t see them improving.
The rucks aren’t great. They lost TDK which I don’t think is the worst but that leaves them reliant on Pittonet and he has a significant amount of potato like qualities. The coach is also a spud, there is no reason at this point to believe he is any good. I am not sure he has ever had a team perform above expectations.
I don’t want to write them off entirely as they have some serious talent at the top end and if all of that talent stayed fit then they could give finals a shake but realistically they lost more talent than they brought in this season and in all likelihood they are going to have a little slide down the ladder. I think 11th-14th.