Something seriously wrong with the club (Part 1, May 2019)

Why not? Its what the player/s are not saying about not winning! Its not just about NOT winning! Many players won’t honestly say what they are feeling while they are contracted. Hardly any are as honest as Connor was, after he pulled the plug.

I don’t see Essendon being where I hope to be, in the next couple of years. I want a trade to a club, where I might be playing finals with a shot @ a premiership.

It may also be about not being happy with the current set up, what ever that means to them not us, to them. Players are becoming like cattle being paraded around the ring. Where would you rather be somewhere where you have a chance of fulfilling your dreams or stuck somewhere being a bottom feeder? The choice is all yours, get out while you have currency and worth to another club. How many players think like that but perhaps say nothing remotely like that? Not many.

Being a one club player is not as popular as it once was. It doesn’t mean what it once did.

Just a summary of what was said on fox footy last night.

1 Like

Is he looking we the problems really are? Or is he just cutting the most obvious? A clean-out is a clean out. I don’t think we are having one of those.

You’re not going anywhere, regardless of tactical gameplans, if the playing group is split.

The question is what is driving that split, because that dictates what actions will work and what may be a complete waste of time.

11 Likes

EXZACERY!!! Find the problem and deal with the problem. Please do not take the easy way out which is usually the way this club deals with problems. No more band aids and sticky tape.

I suspect it is the older saga generation who are the problem. The younger players are trying to drive success and a change in attitude and the older ones are not buying in. Just an opinion.

4 Likes

After thinking about it for awhile I’ve decided I’m not going to stress anymore. All clubs have bad years and we are due a good clear-out. Some changes will be the right one and some will be wrong. As for the players, if they decide to leave rather than help the club reset then let them go. We’ll get new players who will be keen to be part of a rebuild.

1 Like

Sometimes things are not what they seem. Unless you under or over and around its hard to get a complete picture.

If the biggest gripe some senior players have is playing a finished bloke… well, all you can do is laugh.

4 Likes

And one that makes quite a lot of sense.

That’s why the club needs to do a full rebuild now. From what i’ve heard this and next years drafts are very strong (Despite being heavily compromised) and if these older players are having the sulks because their best bud didn’t get a send off game then get what we can for them and get them out of the club.

Look what Port did to their club in 1 draft/trade period. Got rid of the sook Wingard and bought in 4 or 5 really good kids, 3 of which may be 10+ year stars.

1 Like

I think there is a big gap between the older players and the younger players. I first noticed this when Goddard left. After his farewell speech both Hurley and Hooker stood up and spoke glowingly and lovingly about Goddard. But it seemed the younger players seemed a bit…meh.

1 Like

You reckon we’ll get first rounders for Hooker? :smiley:

Depends on who wants him or if anyone wants him. He might decide to allow the club to pay him out, if he doesn’t get any offers. He might ask for a trade back to W.A.

If Hooker is leaving there are only two options that will happen imo: he either retires as he has had enough or he goes to play in WA.

No. Which is why i never mentioned a first rounder.

Well they don’t give you elite kids just for sacking old blokes or sooks.

Yes. Treat the problem, not the symptoms.

2 Likes

I reckon you could have given Beachcomber a farewell game.

Yes, I know, the fitness report saying he was fine comes from Leigh Farking Montagna, but still.

We need a culture change, yes. Not giving players like T-Bell a farewell, particularly in a dead rubber, is not part of any culture we should be aiming for.

4 Likes

As Ive posted previously, I just hope there’s someone of influence within the club that can sort through the symptoms and underlying causes, know which is which , and take appropriate action.

4 Likes

We should be picking our best 22 every week to win.
Bellchambers isn’t in our best 22 so he doesn’t get a game. This will put pressure on everyone to work extremely hard to stay in the team. I don’t know about how that fits in with culture but it would make for a more competitive team each week.

1 Like