The Hanger Vs The Valley

This article got me thinking. The AFL building two ovals in the centre of the Valley, imagine if timings were on our side a decade ago and we could’ve investigated moving from Windy Hill to a new facility inside this redeveloped racetrack? Likely lots of land inside the track.

Obviously I don’t know the ins and outs, however in principle it’d worth knowing whether the Valley was ever considered as a potential site for the Club when we actually moved a decade ago.

The Demons considering Caulfield track. The Bombers at the Valley would’ve kept Essendon in its heartland.

Its not too late.

Andrew Welsh needs to dip into his deep, DEEP pockets.

4 Likes

The Hangar is more than just an oval.
It’s ours to use as we like. Monday to Friday and on weekends.
We’d be renting there. And they wouldn’t have the space we have for our admin nor would it have the facilities for the players, coaches and support staff (AFL, VFL, AFLW & VFLW).

I’d prefer us getting our own facilities that we have full control over (even if it is out in Tullamarine) than to share it with a function that is very different to the AFL industry.

5 Likes

Gonna post it?

But the proposal to build grounds inside the Cox Plate track as part of a major redevelopment is just one of many options being considered by the Moonee Valley Racing Club.

Sounds like they’re looking to the State Government to subsidise them and get them out of having to implement their approved masterplan.

1 Like

They originally agreed to provide some public sporting grounds on the infield, then stepped back to “there will be grass and sometimes we won’t use it for parking”.

You can’t put anything substantial there without blocking vision of the track.

4 Likes

I imagine there’s a fair bit of water that needs to go under the bridge with tv rights for Moonee valley to work. There was a test case where some people lived across the road and streamed the view from their balcony for free online including during race days and it’s was deemed totally fine because it was just the view they had. There’s no way a pay TV network is going to cop AFL games being live streamed for free.

1 Like

get rid of the flood wall around flemington

4 Likes

A move to the Valley would place us closer to our spiritual home but…why change somethings that’s working well now.

LOL Totally unbiased.

Grew up in walker street just a couple streets over from the racecourse, only moved out a few years ago, shattered is an understatement if this goes through :joy:

2 Likes

Apart from a oval and a scoreboard you wouldn’t be allowed to build anything else cause it would obstruct the view on racedays
Pass

1 Like

I’m sure that would be something we’d be able to work out. Just like we did with the bowls club.

get rid of horse racing, build more golf courses

3 Likes

I could think of nothing worse than having the EFC train in the middle of a ■■■■■■■ horse racing track.

Looney tunes stuff.

I’d prefer Fortitude Valley.

1 Like

You could build a fantastic stadium there and get rid of racing that is already dying a slow death. Close to tram, train, freeway and no wind and no aircraft.

Developers have their greedy eyes on it for residential

Well youre happy for Essendon to play at Marvel so who are you to judge.

1 Like

Marvel’s a perfectly fine stadium. If you don’t like it don’t go to it.

1 Like

……well……residential could be useful atm to be honest.

They’re already adding 2000 dwellings in the western portion of the land (Grandstand to move to the northern edge of the land).