Played a very large part, I don’t rate English that highly and he was BoG by a country mile. As I said above, goldie also gave him a bath.
My biggest problem with this is that players like zaka, tippa, Fantasia and a few others are untouchable when in horrific form (not saying that’s the case right now)
6 defenders on the field and one on the bench. The past few weeks, that 7th defender used to help with rotations in the backline has been Raz.
My point is that we bring in another defender, it would free up Raz to play forward again (in an area of the ground where we clearly do have problems).
Lol Philips is trash. I wouldn’t have dropped him (Bellchambers just can’t move) - but really? Getting worked up about us dropping a 28 year old who has been OBLITERATED two weeks running is pretty cooked.
The forward line thing… yeah I think its a mistake. I think if Fantasia is genuinely playing forward then we just don’t need Cahill in the team - and he looked a mile off it. That said, I went full BBlitz about Ham being retained in the team vs the Pies and he played pretty well.
Also pretty funny how many people are potting Hibberd after calling for him to get a game for a month. For all the talk of favourites (gee that “where’s the photos” bit never gets old) the coaches have backed several developing players (Ham, Hibberd, Cahill) probably more than they have earned. Whilst many Blitzers seem to think that Jimmy “I kicked 3 goals a few years ago” Stewart is suddenly the answer to our forward line woes.
Once we get past about name 25 or 26 on the list, they’ve all got issues. Too light, poxy skills, completely unproven etc.
And we’ve been dipping that low since round 1, and we’re now dipping into name 30+.
The coaches will be shuffling deckchairs, but that’s all.
I don’t think it’s realistic to expect swapping Bellcho for Phillips (or Hibberd/Cutler or Townsend/Stewart etc) to change the course of a season.
It may snag us a win or two. It any one of them was legit good, they’d have been in already.
Daniher and Stringer are the answer. But they’re unavailable. Hooker is out as well. Clearly we need another key forward target, so either Stewart gets his chance or… what? Two rucks?
Genuinely curious to know what you think our forward set up should be, given the players we currently have available.
Need Stewart as another tall option. Not expecting him to kick a bag of goals but will help McKernan out. And at points with the two tall forwards, the small forwards will have an opportunity to crumb the ball.
Better option than kicking the ball long to Tippa.