Track Off - Rubber Soul vs Revolver

General Gibberish Forums The Dog's Breakfast
21

A track that’s influential to this day vs legit one of the worst they ever did?
Yeah.

1 Like
22

I haven’t done track 2.
And perhaps I won’t.

1 Like
23

This is an excellent thread @wimmera1

2 Likes
24

I thought so.
Happy to see the format continue, if done in good faith.

1 Like
25

Track 8.

  • Good Day Sunshine
  • What Goes On
0 voters
26

Yep. Toughest one.

Any song that I’ve done at pub karaoke is always getting the nod though.

27

Poor Ringo.

3 Likes
28

A lot of the cool kids probably wont give Yellow Submarine the chocolates…but I do not care. Its epic. I’m an unashamed superfan.

Although I still wouldve have liked to have seen it completed as the original vehicle for Lennons voice, as theres a haunting sorta melancholy to it in the early stages.

6 Likes
29

Track 9.
Two great underrated John songs.

  • And Your Bird Can Sing
  • Girl
0 voters
30

Dang

1 Like
31

Reminder that I accidentally wiped everyone’s Track 5 votes.

32

Track 10.

  • I’m Looking Through You
  • For No One
0 voters
33

Jeez. That’s tough

1 Like
34

@wimmera1, this is brilliant. I hate you.

3 Likes
35

Track 2 Norwegian v Eleanor: John’s lovely melody v Paul’s orchestral blast. Both pretentious at times, JWL’s effort is a little Dylan/adulterer tryhard for mine even if Sir JPMcC is compassionately bleak. The strings are so good on ER they still sound great alone on Anthology. Rigby adds something new while Wood is just a very good standard of tune.

3 Likes
36

Dylan went on to pretty much rip off NW with 4th Time Around.

37

Track 11.

Here’s an easier one, then.

  • In My Life
  • Doctor Robert
0 voters
38

Track 3 Only Sleeping v Won’t See Me: the quality drops. Some nice ideas but neither really grabs you- You Won’t See Me at least raises the tempo and has some nice backing vocals.

1 Like
39

Track 12.

  • Wait
  • I Want To Tell You
0 voters
40

Still not as easy as it should be.

1 Like