Trade Talk 2019 Pt2

Football Discussion Trade week Duursma head in
6610

GWS list manager basically said Bonar is available to a good home for pick 30 this morning. No one has come hard for him yet with bigger deals taking place but he is definitely available if we want to take the punt.

McCartney said Bonar had a really good year as an inside mid in '18 before playing more forward this year. The log-jam of inside mids at GWS have him open to coming home if the right opportunity arises.

If we hold Joe and have picks: 31, 33, 57, 65, 70, 88
Cutler - 57 or 65
Phillips -70

Do we give up 33 for Bonar?

1 Like
6611

I think so. Or SPP

6612

Come hard
Bigger
Inside
Arises
Erm… up

6613

How about this 3 way?
Sydney.get Daniher & Carlton’s future 2nd rounder
Carlton get. Pick 5 and papley
Essendon get pick 9 and Harry Mckay

1 Like
6614

Carlton would not give up McKay.

6615

Not even I gave up Bonars at 33.

1 Like
6616

Carltons forwardline potentially looks pretty good next year

Hf: McGovern Curnow Martin
F: Betts McKay Papley

6617

Hf: Injury prone - over rated - over rated
F: cooked - meh - good

4 Likes
6618

McKay is a very good prospect.

14 Likes
6619

That forward line is better than anything we produced this year

6 Likes
6620

If we can keep Daniher

Hf: Stringer Daniher Smith
F: Fantasia MCKERNAN McDonald-Tipungwuti

but also depth of Snelling, Mosquito, Stewart

i mean its no Lynch and Reiwoldt but its not bad

2 Likes
6621

Bonar’s 2019 NEAFL stats aren’t astonishing or anything.

19.8 disposals, 2.3 marks, 6.2 tackles, 0.6 goals.

6622

I’d prefer a 3 way involving Bonar.

2 Likes
6623

Two of them aren’t at the club yet, one is already injured, another was injured most of last year.

6624

id rather SPP

B: Saad Hooker Ambrose
Hb: McKenna Hurley Heppell
C: Cutler Powell-Pepper Zaharakis
Hf: Smith Daniher Stringer
F: Fantasia McKernan McDonald-Tipungwuti
R: Draper Shiel Merrett
Int: Gleeson Parish McGrath Francis

Cutler and SPP add some size to the mids.
Draper to add some intensity ti the ruck contest.

would even consider Jenkins for McKernan at least would be decent depth.

6625

Yes!!! I’m so happy right now. What a bunch of turkeys.

6626

I would prefer Jenkins on the list instead of Brown

4 Likes
6627

I wonder why Jenkins is having so much trouble attracting any interest. Were the rumours about him feeding Caro inside info true and so clubs are wary of him?

1 Like
6628

Because once team worked out he got most of his goals with over the top joe the gooses and started keeping a man back, his goals dried up and he ended up in the SANFL.

He’s built like a KPF but plays like a goal sneak and is old and on heaps of money.

Not very appealing.

5 Likes
6629

He is very much an “uncontested” ball player, like Mitch Brown.

They are effectively tall, (very) outside smalls.