Have seen glimpses of the lug this year to see that lug will be a great player. There was little debate that MCG was more ready to go of the 2. A lot wanted lug as he was a goal kicking mid, and for some reason thought had higher potential. But a few myself included wanted MCG. He just seemed to have a harder edge, more of an inside game, and quicker. Saw the second efforts and the one per-centers. Plus has really stood up in big games.
Lug on the other hand is an all class silky smooth type player, who was taller (remember much said about this) and kicks the goals (I couldn't care less about that compared to what the harder edge player brings).
But I still think both including Setterfeild and tarranto will be great players, and there is no way to know was right for at least 3 years.
In anycase we have MCG and he has more than exceeded my expectations so far. The real interesting ones are the ones we took later in the draft.