Because Brad is all about results right now
1 Like
Lol so a compromised pre season for a player who didn’t deserve another year to begin with. Great list management.
2 Likes
“Don’t hurry back Jye”. No, that’s not nice. I’m probably on my own here, but I still think there’s a player there. His confidence was just so shot this year. Also, how many times did he hit the post? His 2024 was cursed!
2 Likes
No mad Monday?
I think so aswell he was a totally different player at Southies when he was drafted he had speed and he was clean in he’s ground ball and knew where the goals where.
Then that first full season went at goal a game so here’s hoping it’s just a massive case of second year blues
2 Likes
For me it’s his hands. They are brutal. Just rarely any clean possession
5 Likes
I’m worried about his feet and legs as well…he’s treacle slow and can’t hit a target or kick a goal. No idea why we extended him for a year…would love to know! If you can get Rosa on your podcast please ask him what exactly it is about Menzie that made them re-sign him for 12 months. Genuinely curious to know…
It’s his legs……slow slow slow
If he plays a single game of AFL next year ahead of Kako or ElHawli I’ll microwave my Reimers badge
11 Likes
Reimers badge. Hilarious
Had it strapped all year and could hardly get his arm above his shoulder. Tried to take marks with his bum out and not his hands up. Was just so obvious he was restricted.
1 Like
Why did they give him a contract so early? No one wants him…
Fumbles. Slow decision maker. Slow
Could be paying him next to nothing anyway. Waiting may not have lowered the price further.
1 Like
Clogging up the list is the problem, not the dollars
1 Like
Just for once, I’d truly love you to go “yeah this is a fkn terrible decision”
Just once 
8 Likes
You could put this in most of our players threads and it would be correct.
2 Likes
It beggars belief.
For whatever reason, he must be a Scotty favourite.
The litmus test will be if Weid is not delisted.
With Balders gone … does that enhance Weid’s chances as defensive depth?
Oh, please - NO.