How do you rig it so that Mills has such a good rookie year ? It's got me stumped.In spite of being the preferred #5 pick amongst many Blitzers, Oliver won the Morrish last year then fell right out of Rising star contention and only managed 13 games at AFL level. Try and figure that one out as well.
Do you have high hopes for Francis even though he only played a few games at AFL level?
Whilst different players, Oliver didn’t play the full season at AFL level for the same reason; his aerobic capacity wasn’t allowing him to run out games and his time on ground had to be managed incredibly.
Players mature at different rates. Oliver showed to all that he has the raw materials to be an absolute gun. He is fearless inside the contest, strong, can burst out of a stoppage and he has the added dimension of being a good overhead mark.
The fact that he doesn’t have the athletic profile to permit him to play out full games and to back up properly meant that he was no chance to win the rising star but MFC will be deservedly excited with what he can become provided they have actually turned the corner with their player development.
This award is not about forecasting how good they will be, just how they played in their first season. Rhys Palmer winning vs Danger and Rioli etc.
Of course my comment was rhetorical. Olivers key averages are almost the same as Darcy. He got zilch votes from 13 games, Darcy played 20 and got 19 votes. Same can be said of Petracca who got maybe 1 or 2 votes ( cant be bothered checking on this)
In reality the voting is about which of the good players get noticed by the judges regularly and that means key games that are telecast on Friday and Saturday nights. .