#43 Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti - WALLA MACCA TIPPA - till 2022

Be nice if the club could give an update how Walla is going

We might hear something at some stage. Or not. Either way it doesn’t really matter.

2 Likes

At this point we don’t have any details. Our first game is still 13 weeks away. Far from ideal but let’s not overreact or panic at this point. It’s a long year and he’s got plenty of time to get himself and his body right and play the majority of the season.

Why are there not cameras planted in front of wallas house at the moment stalking his every move? Come to think of it i havent seen live footage of walla for several hours, how do we know he hasnt been sucked into a black hole? EFC has been reckless with health and wellbeing in the past so it wouldnt surprise me if he has. I demand an immediate update on Walla. Stat.

If they could surgically remove his leg and post it to me so I may inspect his calf, that would also be great.

1 Like

Sadly this is not what the team or Walla needed right now. Unlikely to be there till mid season. Unfortunately the lack of fitness make getting fit harder and the risk of injury higher.

I would be surprised if he plays much at all in 2022 and as such we should take both Fejo and Tex in the SSP.

2 Likes

Come on down Lonie!

Smith will have to play as a small fwd

Snelling,Smith,Lonie

Aren’t they the same player

Hadnt he played some crazy amount of games in a row preceding the issue end of season?

It is the first time.

It’s just the extension of what had occurred still leading up to preseason beginning.

Most of us have NFI what is at the heart of the matter, obv it must have been a pretty big deal

Who knows if club just told him post season to go off and do what he needed to be happy even if that involved kicking back and no training.

Someone on blitz had noted he’d begun his own separate PT training leading up to the season however which was clearly needed as starting from a fair way back. Was also noted he was making progress and positive about things as they broke for Xmas.

Maybe he’s pushed himself too hard in the running trying to play catch up and here we are with calf issue.

Can only hope he maintains good spirits despite this setback. Week or so off his feet and then back into the club with the boys getting around him should make sure he does.

11 Likes

If we even consider Lonie for a senior list/rookie spot in the words of Terry Wallace, ā€œI’ll spew up!ā€

1 Like

We don’t have much of a choice if walla misses a lot of games

We have plenty of choice without adding a St Kilda list clogger to our list. There is no point in adding players that have zero elite features to the list. If we add a player to the list I would expect they add elite speed or foot skills or clearance skills or in this case goalkicking skills (or at least the potential of the skills). Jack Lonie possesses none of the above.

3 Likes

Lonie is a very average player.

5 Likes

nunchuck skills, bow hunting skills, computer hacking skills

3 Likes

Have you actually tried to fit everyone into a best 22?
There’s spots for 2 or 3 at most, forwards outside of Jones, Stringer & 2MP.
Leaving aside the taller options like Francis, Baldwin & Langford,
You’ve got to fit in Snelling Smith Shiel ( or another mid like McGrath or Caldwell) Perkins Waterman Guelfi Ham Hird Hobbs Lord & possibly Tex.

That’s 11 players assuming we play 3 smaller forwards.
And Lonie is pushing to make the bottom 4 of that list.

3 Likes

fair points. For mine- he ended last season in not the greatest physical shape, and has returned for pre season in not the greatest physical shape.

I hope he gets better and gets back to the Tippa of old. But he is getting older now, so it’s a bit of a concern

1 Like

Lonie makes no sense, We aren’t (Probably won’t be) winning the flag in 2022 so get development games into our multiple young players if our current senior guys are injured.

5 Likes

Jack Lonie is hot garbage.

2 Likes

why the ā– ā– ā– ā–  are we talking about jack ā– ā– ā– ā– ā– ā– ā–  lonie in any capacity on this forum?

2 Likes

gibbons would be a better option than lonie ffs

1 Like

image

11 Likes