#6 Jye Caldwell - thru 2028

Which is, by definition, a first round pick. For a kid that has injury issues and has so far produced very little on field.

Look at the kids GWS has let go in the past five years that fit those criteria… and they haven’t been getting anywhere near pick 18 for them… most of these fringe kids are getting traded for 3rd/4th rounders…

I’m not saying he wasn’t worth it, or that I am overly upset about the trade at all… but compared to what others are paying for GWS kids (and they still have a full stable of them) we paid a steep price.

Put it this way… we ‘paid’ more for Caldwell than we did for Saad a few years back…

2 Likes

Caldwell stats over his 11 games so far.

Stats suggest his game against the Roos was pretty good. Highlights aren’t particularly special and he was clearly playing second (third?) fiddle at GWS but I definitely think there’s something to work with.

The comparisons of a faster, cleaner and more physical / aggressive Parish seem pretty on point for mine.

I think his intent around the ball will be welcomed.

edit: Found some mistakes… deal with it…

Surprised folks aren’t liking the highlights package - from a small account of games you get some good tackling intent, strong work in close and an ability to find some space / impact the scoreboard.

Will get every chance next year and look forward to seeing his growth.

4 Likes

Some of our established players would kill for some of those numbers

Any guesses as to what jumper # he will get?

6 , 2 , 13 available

Give me the amount of early round picks they have had, access to some internet phantom drafts, and a random number generator, and I reckon I’d get real close to identifying talent just as well as GWS have.

5 Likes

2 is definitely not available to anyone shorter than 2029 mm

13 Likes

Been given 6

10 Likes

This!

I expect it will be retired for at least a few years to honour T Bell.

Geoff Gosper’s old number.

2 Likes

Interesting to watch this back

20 Likes

They definitely rated Caldwell that’s for sure.

Can’t wait to see what he can do.

2 Likes

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/subscribe/news/1/?sourceCode=HSWEB_MRE170_a_FBK&dest=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.heraldsun.com.au%2Fsport%2Fafl%2Fnews%2Fcarlton-has-backed-out-at-the-last-minute-on-an-adam-saad-deal-with-essendon%2Fnews-story%2F17db9a8d70e4808e72bd14108f0e3b04&memtype=anonymous&mode=premium

Anyone have a subscription to post this article?

AFL trade news: How Essendon sealed Jye Caldwell deal
Essendon recruit Jye Caldwell has revealed the key factor that sold him on a move to Tullamarine. Trade news here.

Chris Cavanagh, News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom

Essendon recruit Jye Caldwell says the promise of more midfield opportunity was a key factor in his move to the Bombers.

The former Greater Western Sydney onballer found his way to Tullamarine in a last-minute deal on Thursday after requesting a move home to Victoria.

Caldwell, who was selected by GWS at pick 11 in the 2018 national draft, managed 11 games in two seasons, struggling to hold a spot in a stacked midfield.

“(Essendon) have said to me that I’ll be playing the inside-mid role that I’ve wanted to play for the last couple of years now,” Caldwell said.

“But they’ve also said I’ll be playing in different positions as well, just to be more versatile, but they’re honing in on that inside-mid role for me.”

Caldwell said he had struck a connection with new Essendon coach Ben Rutten quickly during pre-trade discussions with the Bombers and the club’s proximity to his hometown of Bendigo was also a factor in his decision.

“I spoke to ‘Truck’ (Rutten) a few times and I really liked the way he goes about it,” Caldwell said.

“They’ve got a good young group and it’s close to home as well so I reckon that was probably the main reason why I chose to go to the Bombers.”

SAAD GRILLED ON CALL TO LEAVE BOMBERS

- Nick Smart

Adam Saad has remained coy on the reasons behind his decision to leave Essendon for bitter rival Carlton, although he is adamant so-called difficulties with hub life was not one of them.

The rebounding defender went to Carlton for pick No. 8 and an exchange of late draft picks.

When asked on Thursday why he decided to leave the Bombers, Saad replied:

“There’s a couple of little reasons but I won’t make that public.

“But I just want to say I’m really grateful to the Essendon footy club and Adrian Dodoro for bringing me back home (from Gold Coast) and continuing to play AFL footy.

“It’s been a dream of mine ever since I was a kid to play AFL footy and I made a lot of friends at the club and the staff.

“It’s something I’ll cherish and I’m really grateful to the Essendon footy club.”

Essendon chief executive Xavier Campbell said recently Saad struggled with hub life in 2020, which was part of the reason for his decision to want to leave Tullamarine.

Although, Saad disputed that claim on Thursday.

“I enjoyed the hub and I actually enjoyed it more than I thought (I would),” Saad said.

“There was nice sunshine and it had its challenges at times, (but) the hub had no impact on my decision.

“You sometimes just have to do what’s best for you and your family.

“I’m just really pumped and excited to be at the Carlton Football Club.”

Despite some haggling between the two Victorian heavyweights, Saad said he was always confident a deal would be reached.

He said he was committed to be at Carlton next year once he’d announced his intentions.

“Once I made the decision there was no turning back and I was fully committed to the Carlton Football Club and I was pretty much just waiting for the trade to be done,” he said.

“When it came through yesterday I was actually doing a running session.

“My phone started ringing so I thought ‘the deal must have been done.’”

The 26-year-old said he saw the Blues as an exciting destination club.

“They’ve got a really exciting list and with where the club’s heading, they’re entering a really exciting phase,” he said.

“I just felt like I could get to the club and improve myself as a player and add to the team and see where that takes us.”

3 Likes

Only if they could kill without getting bruised.

Not all heros wear capes

Amazing they would paywall an article that simply quotes exactly what he said in his post trade interview that’s freely available on the Clubs and other websites and absolutely nothing more.

Lol, … Murfoch.

5 Likes

What fkn difference is it for you and your family between ess and carlton??? Hes such a lying snake

3 Likes

With the picks GWS have had you could get rid of all recruiters and read blitz

1 Like

enjoy the wing loser.