How do you work that out? Do we know what each coach votes or is it a guesstimate?
TBF it was a hard match to judge. No-one especially stood out but lots of players worked really hard all game.
In the past I have criticised Zac for being too focused on getting the outside ball, and being shy of contact.
Im not sure how he has done it but that has completely changed this year and this is the best I have ever seen him play for us.
I still think Jobe is the best captain we have had since Hird but Zac isnt far behind, and he is probably a better player than Jobe was now.
The way Brad talks about Brad it’s obvious he would have given Zach the 5. Crazy to think that Ross wouldn’t have Zach in the votes at all.
It was most likely something like this
Coach 1
5 Merrett
4 McGrath
3 Martin
2 Heppell
1 Duursma
Coach 2
5 McGrath
4 Seb Ross
3 Jack Steele
2 Brad Hill
1 Nic Martin
OR
Coach 1
5 Merrett
4 McGrath
3 Seb Ross
2 Heppell
1 Duursma
Coach 2
5 McGrath
4 Nic Martin
3 Jack Steele
2 Brad Hill
1 Seb Ross
My guess it’s the first option. And Brad is Coach 1 and Ross is Coach 2
Just work out the numbers - there was a 9 to McGrath therefore he got 5 and 4
Merrett got 5, however Martin got 4 so did Seb Ross, Steele got 3 and two players got 2 each and Duursma got 1. Process of elimination how the votes could have been given.
they should name names on coaches votes.
Yes definitely hard to work out who was best only consensus seems to be McGrath the others to follow hard to pick. It means that Zach has received votes in all 3 games but not maximum votes yet.
Must be painful doing everything you can to carry your team and still losing by 10 goals. Would understand if he requested trade.
Reckon Merret is the only one who would be filthy after the game.
Nah he will finish his time with this club and probably be as unsuccessful leading the club as the last one, and the one before him (Goddard) and the one before him (Watson) and the one before him (Lloyd).
It’s terrible to think this but I genuinely wish he’d left a couple years ago instead of signing on again. Imagine how good he could be playing with a team of non-spuds and having a chance of a premiership in his career, would’ve loved to see that for him.
Needs to have a shower and an edge
Having a shower because he worked his butt off all night
Trade this poor man. He deserves better.
Get out at the end of season Zachy, don’t ■■■■ away your career with this ■■■■■■■ rabble.
As a fan I’d be devastated but would totally understand.
Zach gives way too much of himself to this pathetic organisation. It isn’t worth your time Zach, you deserve better and another team would truely value you.
I would not have an iota of bad blood for zach if he decided to explore his opportunities elsewhere to obtain the success he rightfully deserves. It may just be the wake up call we need.
5.5 tackles as well.
He’s never had an inside game like this. He’s busting his gut and for nothing.
Meanwhile Parish and Setterfield
He was gutted in his post match interview
Is there is a postive he wont have votes taken off him from the likes of Parish gives him more chance of winning the brownlow