AFL - Terrible Ideas, Too Many Ideas, No Idea…

im all for a cannon in the ground that shoots the ball up.

1 Like

maybe there is something in that.
have a device that comes from under the centre circle shoots the ball up then hides away seamlessly.

1 Like

yup thats exactly it. just eliminates the center bounce entirely

Just drop it from SpiderCam. Can move all over the ground that way. Or use a drone.

5 Likes

Trouble is though that he is crap at both.

2 Likes

AFAIK headgear doesn’t necessarily stop concussion. It might stop impact injuries to the skull, as in prevent you from being a fractured skull, but concussion occurs when the brain experiences an impact or jolt within the head.

8 Likes

Brayshaw wore headgear for his whole senior career unless I’m mistaken. Didn’t help him much.

5 Likes

This was all discussed in the Shane Tuck coronial inquiry. Far more details within that.

If they want footy numbers to fall off a cliff mandate headwear…

If AFL are implementing it, would imagine they are getting a cut out of it from head wear supplier. They only do stuff for the $$

1 Like

He only started wearing the helmet after a series of concussions.

Aah, but the key thing you missed is that the AFL is going to make them wear “AFL-endorsed headgear”.

So no conflict of interest there: AFL changes the rules and gets a big kickback for it. They can then use e the extra $$$ to pay themselves bonuses to reward their hard work.

2 Likes

image

4 Likes

That definitely came to mind. Bring them in, makes us look like we are doing something when in reality they do very little to prevent concussion. Clearly to stop potential litigation…

2 Likes

Nah, drop the ball from a blimp.

2 Likes

Just like my fav game as a kid, speedball 2

10 Likes

They have so much faith in it that they’re not actually implementing it at AFL level…

Doesn’t look good on TV.*

  • I think their claim is that AFL have a large medical team that can help or some such drivel.
1 Like

AFL players, hell all elite level athletes, have access to medical resources well beyond most people. That isn’t drivel, its fact, and the reason concussion protocols (both prevention and management) should be different by levels of sport.

What that article is alluding to is a trial of “fit for purpose” helmets. The AFL is expediting their work on this front in light of the Shane Tuck coronial findings. Helmet use will remain voluntary throughout.

It is worth noting the AFL chief medical officer has hesitation toward compulsory helmets due to (a) a minimal, if not negligible, impact on preventing concussion from current research, and (b) that they may provide a false sense of security and could lead to players acting in a manner which makes them prone to concussion.

4 Likes
Should AFL umpires or Third umpire have option to send players off? ie Jimmy webster / Powell-Pepper
  • Yes
  • No
0 voters

Except that the medical teams are not on the field to stop the player hitting their head and causing concussion. If the AFL believe helmets help in this regard it should be for all players of all levels.

1 Like