Should be 5 changes, would love
Out - Goldstein, Kelly, Menzies, Perkins, Hind
In Bryan, Durham, Caddy, Tsatas, Roberts
But we all know that won’t happen. It’ll probably be
Out - Goldstein rested, Perkins
In - Weidman, Durham
1 Like
Goldy won’t be rested Brad loves him
Can we please do something about Bontempli
I’m sick and tired of seeiing that fark tard running around with no opponent racking up 30 plus dispoals kicking 3 goals
Also can some one please smash
Libba and Weightman into next week couldnt care if we cop another suspension
1 Like
Trying to think why Goldy needs to be dropped. Draper was just as bad.
@Finding_Nino , I admire you passion, but can you stop talking about getting our players to knock out opposition players. Those days are done. Let’s just try to beat them with good contested football.
Still, next week has all the signs of a big win to the Dogs. Just like Port had a point to prove after losing to Melbourne, the Dogs will be wanting to make a big statement after their loss this week. This is a big week for Brad Scott as a coach!
1 Like
Is anyone else worried about Mason Redman’s season so far? I wonder if having Nic Martin in defence has taken away Redman’s ability to impact the game - I have barely noticed him in the 2 games he has played this season.
7 Likes
It’s his haircut.
5 Likes
I’d love to be saying Caddy but he does need to play a couple of VFL games first (and wear a mouth guard.) We also need someone who can provide ruck relief. If not Weiderman, maybe you could put Cox in there
I thought Hayes was losing too many one-on-ones. Eyre’s main issue was that he had iron hands that the ball often just bounced off. He was strong and hard at the ball though.
I guess we see things differently. I thought Eyre showed a lot. Dropped a lot of easy marks but the way he covered the ground reminded me of Darcy Moore. I also liked the way he attacked the contest with aggression. Meanwhile, Reid frustrated me as he always seemed like he’d popped a Valium pill before the game. (Good skills though.)
St Kilda obviously saw something in him since they probably would have signed him had he not torn his hamstring. Collingwood obviously saw something in him as they signed him up to the VFL team, and then signed him this year despite tearing a hamstring again. I didn’t watch any of his VFL games but Collingwood fans who did were very supportive.
1 Like
We aren’t making finals after two s*it performances… so players who should not be playing any further
Menzie - had many chances but isn’t going to cut it
Hepp- been OK, but won’t be playing next next so hes is holding development of someone else
Lav - past it
With Cox - try on a wing for a few games, he is not a backman FFS
Cox to the wing ? Maybe.
I’m trying to imagine how Cox would go on a Langdon, or a Daicos…
he always has a direct opponent. trouble is is that he is a significantly better player than that opponent
he’s far too good a player to just except someone to stand with him to negate his presence
3 Likes
I’d be happy if we could keep Bont to 30 possessions and 3 goals.
I wonder this too. The Martin move, while it may have seemed like a good idea, has upset the apple cart in a number of ways I think.
1 Like
The answer is no, we never do anything with Sidebottom or Pendlebury on Anzac Day for the last decade why would we with Bont
Caldwell played a few games as a tagger and did fantastic but let’s not do that anymore.
Coaches including Brad have NFI.
2 Likes
Yep- very frustrating listening to Hodge say that we needed someone out the back at the centre bounce to stop Rozee…yet we did nothing.
I hope they watch the replay with the commentary on….but I doubt it.
3 Likes
pendles is tagging himself these days
1 Like
Caldwell went to Rozee and couldnt remotely stay with him
1 Like
Zero impact, in fact he has been more costly if anything.
He needs to lift and starts Friday night, all mindset.
He wants to be a future leader start showing it
1 Like