B: Wanganeen, Carlisle, Hardwick HB: McPhee, Merrett, Houli C: Hawker, Blumfield, Heffernan HF: Monfries, Jenkins, Melksham F: Cockatoo-Collins, Salmon, Moorcroft R: J Madden, Carracella, ? IC: Cummings, Ryder, Manton, Crameri, Crow, TaubertYep. Comfortably.
Glenn Kilpatrick?
B: Wanganeen, Carlisle, Hardwick HB: McPhee, Merrett, Houli C: Hawker, Blumfield, Heffernan HF: Monfries, Jenkins, Melksham F: Cockatoo-Collins, Salmon, Moorcroft R: J Madden, Carracella, ? IC: Cummings, Ryder, Manton, Crameri, Crow, TaubertYep. Comfortably.
Greg Anderson went alright
B: Wanganeen, Carlisle, Hardwick HB: McPhee, Merrett, Houli C: Hawker, Blumfield, Heffernan HF: Monfries, Jenkins, Melksham F: Cockatoo-Collins, Salmon, Moorcroft R: J Madden, Carracella, ? IC: Cummings, Ryder, Manton, Crameri, Crow, TaubertYep. Comfortably.
Glenn Kilpatrick?
Gotta have some standards. Haven’t got…who was that guy who played for four clubs and went in that deal?
Anyway, haven’t got him either. Or Raines or Richardson.
I’m sure I’ve forgotten some pretty big names of the last 30 odd years though.
Fair shout putting Greg Anderson in there, was a top player and was devo when he left for the Crows. Cost him a premiership, probably would’ve been in that side ahead of Paul Hills, the man who took over his #11…
B: Wanganeen, Carlisle, Hardwick HB: McPhee, Merrett, Houli C: Hawker, Blumfield, Anderson HF: Monfries, Jenkins, Melksham F: Cockatoo-Collins, Salmon, Moorcroft R: J Madden, Carracella, Heffernan IC: Cummings, Ryder, Manton, Crameri, Crow, TaubertYep. Comfortably.
A few changes:
Dean Solomon in the backline. I’d shift McPhee in as a forward.
Rick Olarenshaw in for Melksham (debatable I guess).
Merv Neagle in for Heffernan.
I’d go Craig O’brien above Moorcroft.
I’d forgotten about Neagle to Sydney!
Fair calls.
I’d take some shifting on Moorcroft but that’s a personal thing.
That team needs some Kepler Bradley . On the wing of course
Bit stiff to leave out Super Ted Richards from that backline as well
Salmon, madden, Ryder, Cummings, merrett, Carlisle, Jenkins…
That’s a lot of quality talls 
Salmon, madden, Ryder, Cummings, merrett, Carlisle, Jenkins...That’s a lot of quality talls
Ted Richards as well.
I’d have Mark Johnson in that team somewhere as well
I'd have Mark Johnson in that team somewhere as well
Good point. Get Houli the fark outta there for MJ
Agree on Mark Johnson and Ted Richards. I’d forgotten Mark Johnson had played for Freo.
Does Milne qualify? Never drafted by us, but played 50 ess reserve games.
Derek Kickett
Definitely.
And thanks for reminding me that it was Dale I meant earlier.
B: Wanganeen, Carlisle, Hardwick HB: Richards, Merrett, Solomon C: Hawker, Neagle, Anderson HF: Monfries, Jenkins, Kickett F: Cockatoo-Collins, Salmon, Moorcroft R: J Madden, Carracella, M Johnson IC: Cummings, Ryder, Crameri, BlumfieldCrow, Taubert, Melksham, McPhee, Houli, Heffernan, Manson
Okay?
Barry Davis HBF
Alan Noonan CHF (Richmond in his last year in vfl)
I had their numbers on my jumper as a kid.
Johnny Williams CHB all Australian, 3rd in Brownlow. (Went to Collingwood)
Paul Sproule deserves a spot too.
Barry Davis HBF Alan Noonan CHF (Richmond in his last year in vfl) I had their numbers on my jumper as a kid.Johnny Williams CHB all Australian, 3rd in Brownlow. (Went to Collingwood)
Paul Sproule deserves a spot too.
There probably should be two teams.
Have a best 22 of players we lost vs best 22 of players we traded in.
Have a best 22 of players we lost vs best 22 of players we traded in.
F: Mark Williams - Doc Wheildon - Justin Murphy
Have a best 22 of players we lost vs best 22 of players we traded in.
Will have missed some old players. Interstate transfers would change it dramatically.
B Michael A Daniher Barnard
HB Goddard Wellman McPhee
C Murphy Tuddenham Doolan
R Barnes Chapman Denham
HF Cooney T Daniher Fraser
F Cupido Lloyd Elshaug
IC Camporeale Allen Young Prismall
Prefer this group of talls tbh even if i was cheeky with Lloyd.