3 weeks upheld.
1 Like
8 tackles & 3 goals to 3QT. Not bad for a guy some say is āNot AFL standardā
11 Likes
Another guy not given a go coz brad had it in for him, forging a decent career elsewhere.
I donāt think we miss him now we have caddy, but I think at the time weid was getting games, everybody was calling for a debut all year, he won the vfl bnf, then got delisted.
10 Likes
Is he better than Jones, who just signed another 2 year deal?
No.
2 Likes
I have zero info but recall whispers or speculation on here that off field was as much or more a factor in the delisting as on field, if you catch my drift, allegedly (I seriously donāt have any info) (I know it sounds like I kinda do but I donāt) (I donāt)
1 Like
Same whispers that a bunch on here also go with.
May be true, may not. We listed him as emergency a bunch of times though so it canāt have been that bad?
Was always in ripping shape.
Gerreyn will save us
2 Likes
Based on these surface level stats they are almost identical, except Voss kicks .07 more goals per game and 1.1 more clearances.
Thatās subjective.
All I know is that he is an AFL standard player as Iāve thought all along
2 Likes
Whatās going on with those āRating Pointsā? Jones is ābelow averageāā¦ but still has more than 3.5 times as many as Voss!
Would take Voss in a heartbeat over Jones.
9 Likes
jones has played more games.
1 Like
He has, but the reason theyāre both āBelow Averageā despite how big the gap seems to be is that āBelow Averageā covers the bottom third of players, and the top end of the scale is someone like Bontempelli whoās around 670. So the difference between 46 and 165 just isnāt that much. Like, Redman has kicked three times as many goals as Roberts, but theyāre both in the category ākicked ā ā ā ā all goalsā.
Voss looks good in a better team
He would probably suck if he played for Essendon
1 Like
Archie May >>>>>> P Voss
2 Likes
Voss is a far better player than Jones.
He can probably play the wing better than Jones too.
2 Likes
Yeah as heās shown by kicking more goals at every level heās played.
ā¦checks VFL
ā¦checks WAFL
Hmm. At least we can hope.
1 Like
Both are ordinary players - Jones is just VFL standard and our coach keeps playing him. Itās crazy. With our new MSD recruits - Iād say Jones will struggle to get another game
4 Likes
Agreed.
It just makes the 2 year extension for Jones absolutely inexcusable.
4 Likes
Iām genuinely excited about Archie May. The kid has talent and will show most of our list how to train hard and prepare. Will embarrass many of our guys like Jones cox and Perkins who look unfit and under prepared for AFL football
4 Likes