GWS Players - Who do we want?

Don’t mind Devon either. Feel he’d complement Pig Hibberd & Hams.

Quoted Post

Hoskin-Elliott thanks

Yep absolutely

I am sure we could find room for that Cameron bloke to

Quoted Post

Quoted Post
Hoskin-Elliott thanks

Yep absolutely

He’s from Melbourne, yeah? I met his younger brother not long ago - the name cannot be common.

You would think we’d accept any of them as hopefully our first pick is late enough that they’d be better. Plus they would all be plug and play by now.

Hoskin-Elliott absolute freak. Next Stevie J in my eyes.

That said, if we can get any one of these guys, I’ll be buzzing.

Quoted Post

Hoskin-Elliott absolute freak. Next Stevie J in my eyes.

Pass.

Quoted Post

Quoted Post
Hoskin-Elliott absolute freak. Next Stevie J in my eyes.

Pass.

2nd that.

Way to put me off a bloke.

Throw the book at Hoskin, Treloar, Smith or Cameron.

Not too fussed about Shiel (chronic shoulder problems??) and Coniglio (very inconsistent, even starting at sub at times in 2014).

Quoted Post

Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Hoskin-Elliott absolute freak. Next Stevie J in my eyes.

Pass.

2nd that.

Way to put me off a bloke.

Yeah, I suppose we don’t need ridiculously-skilled players that can win games off their own boot.

Quoted Post

Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Hoskin-Elliott absolute freak. Next Stevie J in my eyes.

Pass.

2nd that.

Way to put me off a bloke.

Yeah, I suppose we don’t need ridiculously-skilled players that can win games off their own boot.

Once somebody is described as ‘Stevie J-like,’ it’s almost a certainty that they’re not.

Quoted Post

Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Hoskin-Elliott absolute freak. Next Stevie J in my eyes.

Pass.

2nd that.

Way to put me off a bloke.

Yeah, I suppose we don’t need ridiculously-skilled players that can win games off their own boot.

Once somebody is described as ‘Stevie J-like,’ it’s almost a certainty that they’re not.

Almost. Except in this case. R18, R21 & R23 last year are cases in point.

Quoted Post

Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Hoskin-Elliott absolute freak. Next Stevie J in my eyes.

Pass.

2nd that.

Way to put me off a bloke.

Yeah, I suppose we don’t need ridiculously-skilled players that can win games off their own boot.

Once somebody is described as ‘Stevie J-like,’ it’s almost a certainty that they’re not.

He’s more Hird/Fyfe like than Stevie J.
Will be a superstar in time.

Cam McCarthy plz

Quoted Post

Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Quoted Post
Hoskin-Elliott absolute freak. Next Stevie J in my eyes.

Pass.

2nd that.

Way to put me off a bloke.

Yeah, I suppose we don’t need ridiculously-skilled players that can win games off their own boot.

Once somebody is described as ‘Stevie J-like,’ it’s almost a certainty that they’re not.

He’s more Hird/Fyfe like than Stevie J.
Will be a superstar in time.

Oh I agree, he’s gonna be top shelf.

I was just riffing on ‘Stevie J’ comparisons in general.

Cameron

Quoted Post

Hoskin-Elliott absolute freak. Next Stevie J in my eyes.

That said, if we can get any one of these guys, I’ll be buzzing.

Steinberg like

Treloar is one of the most talented kids I’ve ever seen at junior level. Heppell level, though having to play in a side full of kids means he hasn’t quite had the same chance to show it.

Shiel would probably be the most reasonable target out of that list wouldn’t he? The rest would cost you an arm and a leg (well, not that they would give up Shiel cheap but the others are rated higher). There is no way we would be able to pay what GWS would ask for Cameron, Treloar, Hoskin-Elliott etc without ruining the balance of our list.

Still, doubt we’d get any of them.

If GWS can’t keep Treloar, they might as well shut the whole place down.