I grew up in a non-aligned family with St Kilda sympathies. My Dad followed St Kilda in the 60s, but lost interest after their premiership and didn’t follow football through the 70s. He started watching football again in the mid-80s, but didn’t support any team, just hated certain teams, namely Carlton, Collingwood, Hawthorn (and later West Coast and Port Adelaide), and loved watching them lose.
I was not really interested in football as a child, and nominally chose Collingwood to support as my best friend in pre-school did. I remember being happy that Collingwood beat Essendon in '91, but only because my friend was happy.
Then in Grade 3 or 4, I fell deeply in love with an Essendon supporter named Melissa. Given I was desperate to try and win her favour, I decided to support Essendon and considered it a sure-fire bet to win her over. It didn’t work. I was heartbroken and ended up moving to a new school the following year. I stubbornly decided to stick with Essendon, despite the rejection.
Similarly, and completely independent of my manipulative motivations, my sister, two years younger, had also decided to support Essendon. She did this to show solidarity with the sole-essendon supporting boy in a class of Collingwood/Carlton/Melbourne supporters, who she felt sorry for. She may have also had a crush on him too, but never admitted as much to me.
Over the next couple of years, my sister became a massive tomboy and became totally into footy, collecting footy cards and even joining an all-male under 11s footy team, where she played full-forward and was mercilessly teased as the only girl. I think she played for a couple years until the age girls were banned from playing.
I’m not sure when I went from nominally supporting Essendon to passionately supporting Essendon but it was sometime in grade 5 or 6. I think I was pulled along by my sister’s enthusiasm and I may have become competitive in seeking to know more about Essendon than she did, as I felt a bit dumb when she mentioned players like Wanganeen that I had never heard of it. I have no idea when I started to follow the team and get emotionally connected to win/losses. I remember being overseas with my parents in 1993 and asking an Australian we met whether we won the grand final or not, so it may not have been till 1994 that I got really into it. My dad would take me and my sister to our first game against Melbourne at the MCG when we got smashed by a bazillion points and Schwartz kicked a million goals. I remember also going to a Geelong game when Gary Ablett dominated us. I don’t remember what the first win I witnesses was, but I went to a string of losing games before I experienced a win. The passion developed quickly, (as did the hatred of Carlton), and I can remember rushing home from school on Anzac Day 1995 to listen to the final quarter of the famous draw, heart in my mouth and stomach churning the entire time.
Looking back, I suspect my Dad also probably hated Essendon, but he won’t admit it now out of respect to his kids. He comes along to Fark Carlton games and delights in Carlton loses, so I think he delights in seeing his kids happy the most.
Also many years later, in my mid-20s, I spotted Melissa at the train station in Essendon gear after an Etihad stadium match (having not seen her since I was 10). Predictably, she was not quite the goddess that my 10 year old self recalled. I think she hopped on a different train quite quickly, but I would have liked to have thanked her for the broken heart in grade 3, as it indirectly led me to support a great club that I’m very proud of, which has brought me so many happy memories in my life. I mean, imagine if she had supported Richmond???