You can only have a limited number of players that small before it becomes an issue. And imo it is already an issue for us. Frequently, we are exposed by one of our smalls being unable to compete man on man in a marking contest.
Whatever happens we just have to hope TBell stays fit. Bringing in Grassy Knoll as a third (second?) ruck is insurance we hopefully don’t need. One midfielder could be handy. Tippa could turn out to be more than handy
This draft was created with the intention of sides filling holes due to injury - our ruck hole a perfect example.
the reality is, smart clubs will use it to get a 6 month look / headstart on 19-22 year olds with upside. Players who would be going 30-70 in next years draft. It is a free hit on Sydney Stack type players. Massive ability but overlooked for other reasons.
We should be taking the two most talented players in the country with our first 2 picks - it is a $70k a pop punt instead of $500k for 2 year contract and usual expenses for a draftee.
I can’t see any reason not to take all 3 picks. Take a back up ruckman as near as possible to ready made (Knoll?), and then 2 of whatever is available that we think might be any good long term. No short term, quick plug and play mediocre types. Go for equivalents of Guelfi, young vfl/sanfl/wafl types who were overlooked in their draft year and who are playing good footy at the next level. I could live with Connellan or Lazzarro if we think there are no other options.
Whoever we take, it gives us the option of retaining them at end year without someone else getting them before us. If we don’t think they are worth keeping, no harm done.
I wonder whether clubs are uncomfortable with pulling a kid away from their club/home state/family etc for a speculative six month try-out…they may feel obliged to a longer commitment to the player in return for the upheaval…(eg. sounds like Coburg could get cleaned out of their best players)
But that isn’t an issue with Essendon VFL players. They don’t have to go anywhere. Their club being inconvenienced is us…
So I agree, give Lazzarro/Connellan and even Landt a go rather than leave unused picks.