I had my doubts
Hold on a second. Do we actually know that he can play midfield?
I want some inside contested ball midst and a defender who can spoil. I nearly imploded last night with the amount of forward half marks to Sydney.
That generally wasnt an inability to spoil. It was an inability to even get to the contest on many occasions! We got totally and utterly outpositioned everywhere.
First rounder + Francis for Dylan shiel please
No you donât. With no saga we get Zerrett with our second rounder. Weâd also have a 2013 first to have used.
JBOMBER: BakerWasAStar:I think youâre being a little hard on Dodoro here.
Put Ryder, Carlisle, Hibberd, Melksham and Crameri back on our list and we are a genuine flag chance this year.
The saga has dealt us a hard hand and we now have to work through it and rebuild certain sections in our structure:
- genuine defensive tall (I would target Rory Thompson ahead of leaver - has genuine height that we need and wonât cost us anywhere near as much).
- genuine midfield bull to replace Jobe e.g. Libba (package him with the Package for our 1st and 2nd round picks)
Do you really believe that? Put in Crameri you have to take out Zerrett & replace him with Melksham. I 100% believe with those players we have a better squad BUT there is still no way in hell we go deep into the finals with that midfield.
No you donât. With no saga we get Zerrett with our second rounder. Weâd also have a 2013 first to have used.
Based on WHAT??? Youâre assuming he would have fallen another 6-7 draft spots.
Ants: JBOMBER: BakerWasAStar:I think youâre being a little hard on Dodoro here.
Put Ryder, Carlisle, Hibberd, Melksham and Crameri back on our list and we are a genuine flag chance this year.
The saga has dealt us a hard hand and we now have to work through it and rebuild certain sections in our structure:
- genuine defensive tall (I would target Rory Thompson ahead of leaver - has genuine height that we need and wonât cost us anywhere near as much).
- genuine midfield bull to replace Jobe e.g. Libba (package him with the Package for our 1st and 2nd round picks)
Do you really believe that? Put in Crameri you have to take out Zerrett & replace him with Melksham. I 100% believe with those players we have a better squad BUT there is still no way in hell we go deep into the finals with that midfield.
No you donât. With no saga we get Zerrett with our second rounder. Weâd also have a 2013 first to have used.
Based on WHAT??? Youâre assuming he would have fallen another 6-7 draft spots.
Sure. Nobody else seemed particularly interested in him.
Getting Stringer, whether right or wrong, you probably have to sell the fact he will get midfield minutes with us. Iâm not for or against us getting him, but to get him to commit to us, and not want to be traded anywhere else, we probably have to go down that path. At best heâs a burst player through there and you rotate him off a forward flank. He wouldnât solve the glaring weakness we have inside the contest as heâd be an outside type of player anyhowâŚ
JBOMBER: Ants: JBOMBER: BakerWasAStar:I think youâre being a little hard on Dodoro here.
Put Ryder, Carlisle, Hibberd, Melksham and Crameri back on our list and we are a genuine flag chance this year.
The saga has dealt us a hard hand and we now have to work through it and rebuild certain sections in our structure:
- genuine defensive tall (I would target Rory Thompson ahead of leaver - has genuine height that we need and wonât cost us anywhere near as much).
- genuine midfield bull to replace Jobe e.g. Libba (package him with the Package for our 1st and 2nd round picks)
Do you really believe that? Put in Crameri you have to take out Zerrett & replace him with Melksham. I 100% believe with those players we have a better squad BUT there is still no way in hell we go deep into the finals with that midfield.
No you donât. With no saga we get Zerrett with our second rounder. Weâd also have a 2013 first to have used.
Based on WHAT??? Youâre assuming he would have fallen another 6-7 draft spots.
Sure. Nobody else seemed particularly interested in him.
Hey lets go full retard & suggest we would have got him as a rookie after Dodoro picked up Cripps, Dumont & Ben Brown. He waited 15 years to get to that draft & his plans were foiled by the saga. Poor Adrian
Our defence isnât exactly going great at the moment either.
Cale Hooker would help
Any player that isnât a KPP or Ruckman should be playing some time in the midfield. Thatâs a requirement of the game in 2017.
Because our forward line will function so much better with him not there
Fair point, but heâd be forward/mid more than mid/forward. We probably need the latter. If he was all that we could get, would you take the punt? Maybe. If this draft is as shallow as being reported it might be a good time to trade out a first rounder. If we could get Rockliff in FA and Stringer that would be handy, that being said we will probably not make any big signingsâŚ
Is OâBrien worth an upgrade?
No.
Heâs not a rookie so youâd have to draft him, not upgrade him. Aint gonna happen.
Rockliff? Would he be on our radar?
We just havenât been linked to him.
A contested, balling winning, clearance beast is what we need ASAP. Does anyone know any genuine midfielders we have been linked too besides Kelly?