Some honest, uncensored thoughts over a glass of red late at night.
Preseason so don't care about the result. All about oogling the youngsters like a filthy pedo.
From what I've seen, a little underwhelmed by the newish rookies tbh. Bar JD of course.
- J.Merrett looks silky and seems to move like a jet. Just can't get the ball in a contest.
- Kav, similar to Merrett, looks ok in space, breaking lines and running with the ball, but opposition seem to punish us going the other way when these guys are in the mid. Though had 5 tackles against GC.
- NOB, another player I've really liked the look of in the past, but development seems to have stagnated. Probably being harsh, but just feel that 3rd yr players on other clubs lists look far more progressed than ours (brad hill, jed anderson, brandon ellis, sam kerridge, elliot yeo, michael talia, lachie neale, dylan buckley, devon smith, seb ross, jack newnes, - adams, greene, wingard and corniglio probably unfair to compare to given they are top 10). Then again now I look at it there are alot of names from that draft that haven't made it / been delisted. Getting impatient anyway. Heppell set the bar too high! :-)
- Zerrett has confused me and probably contributed to tainting my opinion of guys like Kav, Merrett and NOB. Has looked more at home in 2 games than all those guys have in 2 yrs at the club. And that worries me that either the development of these guys hasn't been great, or perhaps they just aren't that good... just yet. But Zerrett for mine has gone past these 3 which is alarming. Obviously doesn't have the tank yet. But like the look of him alot.
- Colyer gets to the right spots, super pace, just panics, over runs and butchers it too much for a permanent senior spot.
- Gleeson, surprisingly liked his poise and decision making under pressure, just his body is a long long way off, maybe 2-3 years.
- Ashby, not done much, but what he did was eye catching. In the Enright mould hopefully. Got pace, skill and seems to read the game, but like Gleeson he's a twig. A while off having the body.
- Steinberg, I tend to disagree with a fair few comments on here about his prospects. He tries his best, goes hard, but looks out of his depth, even in a NAB game. Awkwardly sized, not fast, skills didn't appear great, can't get to enough contests. I just don't see what the appeal is. Good clubman perhaps?
- JD couldn't be happier with.
Where is Van Unen? Is he going to make it or be delisted at years end? No sight of him and he'll be 25 next year. Whats the story.
Those GWS boys Edwards and Aylett - had highish hopes for Edwards but haven't heard much. Aylett limited run vs GC.
Concerned that these 3 can't even get a decent crack at a nab game when the younger guys who played didn't exactly excite the masses (bar JD).
Other clubs appear to have unearthed a few potential diamonds from nowhere. Langford, Wanganeen, Luke McDonald, McDonough, Sam Llyod, Langdon, Buckley, P.Cripps, Matt Crouch, Polec + Macrae (high picks i guess), Clurey, Ramsay, Miles, Georgiou, Kennedy Harris amd Clay Cameron.