Review Thread v Adelaide goal machines

3rd quarter would be ok. Little bit of the 4th.

We won the toss.

3 Likes

It’s all worth watching SOT.

Some good bit’s of play in every qtr, and you get to see where we let it down and perhaps why. That way you can make your own assessment as to whether the team & season are doomed, or if we are on our way to being a team with a shot at the 8 with some more time and match fitness. The 3rd qtr will show how we adjusted & lifted the work rate & tackling, and that the lads learnt how much difference it can make, and that with a bit of Crow type luck with the goals, they could have found themselves right back in it., which would have been no mean feat from where we were at half time.

I always watch a loss, and more closely than a win. It often tells you more than one, but then, I can’t help but come at it from a coaching perspective these days.

4 Likes

It’s hard enough trying to comment on this crap performance of ours without having to battle a Yankee Puritan swear filter as well. FFS, we’re not even allowed to say H-E-L-L.

1 Like

Heppell has been every bit as bad/good as Jobe in rounds 1, 3, and 4, and was clearly worse in round 2. The common theme is the year off, not their age.
Merrett has been down on hurt factor the last 2 weeks as well.

The real problem is that the next rung of our midfielders are already playing in the ones, and so far no one’s really stepping up to take the clearance pressure off the underperforming Jobe and Heppell.

I think the returning players are our biggest problem at them moment. I reackon they believe they are fine, yet are struggling with the game load and refusing to admit it. They are stuffed, need a rest and will be throughout periods of the season. But because of the emotional factor they will not put their hands up and we will be reluctant to drop them.

I think at best we can hope for 3-4 game bursts from them and a limited number in the side. Next year may be different.

I also think they are slotting back into their old ways of indirect, poor handball choices putting guy under the pump or calling for it when they are themselves.

The good news is that we can get games into the younger players throughout the year. Not so Mutch the first year players, but the rest.

I really don’t see the issues so much with Hooker forward, I think he has bee ok, not brilliant, but serviceable.

Hurley really looks lost and stuffed, he has never had a player get ahold of him like tex did in his whole career. He will be doing some sole searching.

Watson appears to have lost a yard, and unless he is winning the clearances he is a liability.

Heppell is either injured or needs a week off, the let down from weeks 1/2 has been huge, time to suck it up and lead.

Stanton is good when he gets it and appears to be clam and making ok decisions, but he can’t get near it enough.

Hocking can’t make the side. Neither can TBell, although I will give him the benefit of the doubt till he plays but I’m not hopeful.

Howlett similar and broke game 1

Colyer is the surprise packet of them, appears to have not missed a beat.

So if this year is about being middle of the pack them we need to make decisions about the next few years now. Games to younger players and their learning a number one.

Stuart and Francis play.

Jerrett gets a long stint so we can find out.

One in form debut player in every five week block.

Dea and Heartly plays the rest of the year.

4 Likes

That’s not entirely true. Two seasons ago, before our players were victimised, many of us here were commenting on the tortoise speed of our midfielders, Jobe, Humphrey, Doice & co. The year off has only exacerbated the existing situation. H-E-L-L, they’re all a year older, so advancing age does have a bearing.

EDIT: I’ve just seen Nocturnal’s post, immediately above this one, which was entered while I was writing this one. He’s spot on !

1 Like

I suggest he looks at the bottom of his shoe first off

3 Likes

Yeah, farking front runners. Imagine only losing three games since rd 9 last year, with one of those being a semi final. Wish we weren’t that good yet!

Thanks goodness that Jenkins and the other big spud didn’t play. Maybe we went in thinking this was good for us and let the guard down. Mind you it probably didn’t help matters that Betts had front and centre attention all week to get him and his team pumped up for the game in front of a home crowd.

[quote=ā€œTeeBee, post:212, topic:10274ā€]

We’ve been badly lacking an intercept marker since Carlise left and Hooker went forward. Hartley was an option but hasn’t backed himself lately with his marking, hence his stint in the twos. Woosha has tried to address it by bringing in Brown with little success.
[/quote]

Are we really? Everyone keeps on biatching on about how we need to move Hooker back, or bring in Hartley, or Dea or Francis to be the ā€œinterceptorā€. It is not as if the oppo have just been blindly banging it in long (apart from Blues waterpolo game) for someone to easily take a grab 3rd man up. A lot of the kicks into our defensive 50 that have been a bit loopy, or are a floater, we do clean up quite well. Which is why we were actually in the top defensive teams for the first three rounds. The Crows were on tonight. They lowered their eyes well. Plus they were kicking them out of their ā– ā– ā– ā– ! [quote=ā€œBLOODSTAINED_DEVILS, post:244, topic:10274ā€]
with a bit of Crow type luck with the goals, they could have found themselves right back in it.
[/quote]

The Footy Gods did verily shine forth from between their buttocks upon the Crows.

1 Like

Its not the end of the world but…

The midfield is so firigging slow If we don’t get the clearance we cannot get the ball back until the opposition turn it over or the umpire bounces it after they goal…and then they win the centre clearance and bang they are off again. Jobe Hep, Goddard and Zaka are way too slow to be playing in the same midfield. Big call but I think its time to push Raz, Colyer and Walla more through the midfield at centre bounces. I hate to even say this but players like Jobe, Goddard,Hocking and Myers will only delay our chances of improving.

Also got to be questions about Kelly now. Was like a rabbit in headlights because of his lack of pace. Its only rd 4 but Hooker forward is a disaster. All Australian defender now a VFL standard forward. Hurley needs help in defence especially as Worsfold has decided Hartley isn’t good enough. Brown was ok last night but not up to it as a key back. Key backs Hooker and Hurley and Stewart and Joe forward.

I’ve been a big Baggers fan but why is he suddenly falling over at every contest? Is it because he is too slow now to play on quick forwards? McGrath gun!

I wonder how long Woosha will keep blaming the fact that some players missed 12 months of footy. Blah Blah Blah

As I said its only Rd 4 but FFS we look ordinary

1 Like

Sometimes you just get beaten by a red hot team at their peak while at their home ground and you just go yep, ā– ā– ā– ā–  they were good and move on. This is one of those times.

9 Likes

Totally agree with the fist sentence (and the fact that they are struggling with the demands AFL footy), but are you f*cking kidding with that second bit?

Do you really think Hurley goes home after having a bag kicked on him with a smile on his face and a sense of satisfaction? Or any of the others? Fk off.

That looks like a team of players who reckon they’re going fine doesn’t it?

The returning players are showing very worrying signs, but you can’t possibly think that they themselves are ignorant of that.

There was a passage of play early in this game that summed it up for me. We turned it over in our forward line and crows player kicked it 50-60 metres to the wing where there were three farking crow players on their own - our defensive accountability in the midfield was really poor. But then you can cheat when essington are trying to deliver the ball in the forward 50 - high probability that we will turn it over.

Walla’s skills as a go to forward

2 Likes

BTW, for those, (I imagine few), … that are interested in a replay, . it’s now available via Sandbelts magnificent little rig.

1 Like

The weekend is f*cked now, isn’t it?

Essendon but more importantly Sydney copping a loss on the same weekend. Condolences mate, tough times!

1 Like

I also thought we had a few nice leads and spear passes there as well. Can’t remember who, McGrath was one, Tippa? Colyer? Irish? Delivery not atrocious, but f@rk Adelaide were red hot and I’d like to have seem Mc and Ambo on Eddie and Tex from get go. Hopefully these two get the premo forwards from now on.

Lol. My weekend has been f*cked since FRANKLIN! got corked by S Hurn 10 minutes into the 1st quarter last Thursday night.

ALL HAIL HURN!