Why would we consider picking up the dregs of another club…again?
Fark me, it’s worked a treat with Woosha hasn’t it?
When we appointed Sheedy in 1981, this club that was considered to be ultra conservative in its nature took a massive gamble and took on an relatively inexperienced assistant coach from a club coming from a sustained period of success, played under one of the game’s absolute coaching greats at the time and from a club considered brutal and unrelenting in its pursuit of success from the late sixties to the early eighties. Richmond were the benchmark of that period but hated, feared and respected by all at the same time.
Sheeds came from that culture and put his stamp over, and a lot of that Richmond mongrel and attitude, on what was considered through the League at the time a club with a soft underbelly.
He turned our club into one of the most brutal, feared and respected units in the League over the next 20-25 years or so.
Sheeds was preceded by both Barry Davis and Bill Stephen who helped build, develop and nurture a young list that would become the core of those feared Sheedy teams in the eighties and into the nineties.
They were probably considered decent coaches but just didn’t have the hardness or knew how to take a young talented list to that next step to realise their talent after spluttering through numerous Elimination Finals thrashings through a barren period of success in the 15 years between our 1968 GF appearance to our next one in '83.
Fast forward almost 40 years and we’ve almost gone full circle back to those pre- Sheedy days.
This ultra conservative, soft underbellied club is now at a critical juncture of its existence and only time will tell whether it’s got the guts to really make the tough decisions about the future of this club or whether it will continue to take the soft option and remain ultra conservative in its decision making.
If it takes someone like a relatively inexperienced assistant coach, with a track record of being a tough uncompromising player, under a modern day coaching legend,
coming from a club with a recent history of sustained success then Mitchell just may be that guy.
I’m pretty sure Sheeds wouldn’t have endeared himself to many Essendon players throughout his playing career given his reputation as a tough footballer who wasn’t adverse to dishing out some whacks behind play or shirtfronts to unsuspecting opponents.
Its time for this club to make some brave calls or consign itself to further decades of mid table mediocrity and irrelevance by backing the current status quo with a few tweaks here and there.
Under Sheedy our club had become a trendsetter and the envy of the League for quite some time, but over the past 15 years we’ve become reactive, a lemming of the League and falling so far behind the trends of modern day football that we have been playing catch up with the stronger clubs but from two or three steps behind at every turn.
Club needs a strong personality to take over again and turn it on its head.