Russia invades Ukraine - 3 - from 23 Oct 2022

It’s interesting that ISR gets cited in same tweets as reports of Russia withdrawing from left bank in Kherson.

The ISR “analysis” was actually the opposite:

Ukraine will also likely recoup combat power from western Kherson and redeploy it to other areas for both defensive and counter-offensive operations. The UAF could conceivably try to chase the Russians across the Dnipro River at various points but is unlikely to do so because the logistics of supporting a Ukrainian lodgment on the eastern bank are very daunting. The UAF is therefore more likely to consolidate its control of the western bank, leave enough force to deter any Russian attempt to cross the river again, and reallocate forces to other areas. The Russian offensive in Donetsk Oblast will likely require the UAF to divert some forces to defend in that area, but the UAF will likely send at least part of the recouped combat power either to reinforce its ongoing counter-offensive in Luhansk Oblast or to open another counter-offensive somewhere else (we will not speculate about where that might be).

The logistics problems for Ukrainian artillery on right bank pounding Russian defences on left bank in support of attacks from flanks look imaginary compared with the problems for demoralized forces ordered to hold another line in Kherson.

3 Likes

I am a total novice on this stuff, and rely on the wise words of the many posters here to have even the faintest idea of what is going on - but is this actually correct?

On the left bank the soldiers were squeezed between the river and the ukrainians coming from the north. On the right bank, if those soldiers are squeezed between the river and the Ukrainians coming from the south, aren’t those Ukrainians coming from the south sandwiched between the Ukrainians coming from Crimea and above?

Hopefully that makes the faintest bit of sense!

The map in that tweet is from the north, looking south. russian forces in Kherson oblast have retreated to the left bank (east) of the dnipro and are between the river and Crimea. (Left and right bank of the river are defined by the direction of its flow. The dnipro flows to the sea.) To support them russia needs to keep the land bridge to russia through Melitopol and Mariupol open. If the AFU make a thrust south from Zaporizhzhia to the Azov sea they can cut russian supply lines and trap them in that pocket, the only escape for them will be through Crimea.

3 Likes
3 Likes

Makes an excellent point there

2 Likes

Pay that one!

2 Likes

The port of Yesyk is on the Russian coast of the Sea of Azov opposite Mariupol.
It does not appear to be a military port, but it does have a military airfield ( the source of the crash into the apartment block in the city).

The correspondence between you guys has messed with my head

I was scanning through the posts and somehow just read that as “Crowd funded drone defence testicles” Lol

4 Likes

what about we amend the moon talk to -

From the moon you can see the great wall of China, hear the noise of India, and feel Ukraine’s courage.

5 Likes

So let’s also try for just “bump me” without specifying gender or age.

1 Like

Can’t even see it from the ISS. It’s a gray thing the width of a narrow road.

1 Like

I love that in a thread about war where footage of actual people dying is regularly posted and we saw a bloke with an unexploded shell in his shoulder three days ago we’re getting testy about a testicle metaphor.

7 Likes

So no “Bump me, Old man”? Lol. Just kidding. Ok, I will try to be gender neutral, for all the women following this thread.

2 Likes

I fear this will be a pyrrhic victory for you.

8 Likes

image

1 Like

Might if confusion re left bank (south) and right bank (north) and Russians not Ukrainians coming from Crimea can be unscrambled.

Meanwhile I’ll just throw in this amusing reference to the reported landing of Ukrainian forces at the Western flank of the left bank:

3 Likes

But rather late.

The recent shift towards ramping up production for munitions needed in a longer war is one of the changes in force posture that recently gave me more confidence the West will not let the Russian fascist regime continue (as it did in Syria):

2 Likes

Real russian Nazis fighting Ukrainian make believe not-real “Nazis” (“nazi jewish led pawns”)

1 Like

Amateurs talk tactics, professionals study logistics.
Logistics is boring. But it’s what drove russia out of Kherson, according to the daily Kos…

I do neither for a job, but I imagine that the minutiae of Logistics resembles the minutiae of OSINT

It’s not real pyrrhic unless it comes from the Pyrr region of France

9 Likes