Turn on the satellite image layer
1 Like
Ok that answers my question. Remaining problem is just my inability to read images.
Just scroll around the airfield and look at all the excavations to protect vehicles. All the random broken tanks and trucks. The chaos and the quantity.
It’s history now, but I find it interesting when these things pop up.
3 Likes
I watched a DW interview overnight on the TV with a former Kremlin adviser in exile.
He suggested that the supply of artillery shells could be the most significant issue facing Russia in prosecuting the War.
While Russia was now in recession, it had substantial reserves and ways around financial sanctions, which would not have an impact on standards of living in the shorter term.
He also said that Putin maintained capacity to crush internal dissent within the Kremlin, the consequences were ‘suicides’ or ‘accidents’ and that it was now difficult to leave.
1 Like
14 separate reports of HIMARS or stormshadow strikes in the south.
https://twitter.com/andrewperpetua/status/1662884716788301833?s=46&t=A5S-z5IJslFoC5SVN0Jodg
3 Likes
That’s a decent thread from Andrew. Seems like lots going on there, plenty of strikes
1 Like
“Fascinating interview with Ukrainian Air Force Brigader General, Serhii Golubtsov.
Covers F-16s, JDAMS, Storm Shadows and everything in between. Worth a full read but some highlights below;
The F-16 meets Ukraine’s strategic requirements; Multi-role and capable of using a wide array of NATO country weapons. AIM-120 air to air missiles will be enough of a threat to force russian fighters and bombers much further back from the border.
3 or 4 squadrons (48-64 F-16s) will be enough to cause russia to abandon its current air strike campaign in one given area.
Lockheed Martin inspected 3 Ukrainian airfields in 2021 for suitability to cater for F-16s;
“It was concluded that the runways and taxiways are perfectly suitable for the normal operation of F-16 aircraft.”
HARM anti-radar missiles completely changed the air defense situation. F-16s will increase their efficiency greatly, given the greater intergration available.
The same will apply to most NATO standard weapons available; the ability to target and respond in real-time.
Zuni unguided rockets supplied to Ukraine earlier this year helped replace stocks of the S-13 rocket used by Ukrainian Su-25s.
They also fly further and have greater accuracy.
JDAMS have been well received.
However, due to the proliferation of russian S-300 & S-400 systems, Ukrainian pilots are only briefly flying to a height of 6-8km before launch which reduces the range of the bombs to 40-50km.
Regarding Storm Shadow, Golubtsov doesn’t say too much.
He mentions long range capabilities are something the Ukrainian Air Force continues to expand upon and will work to increase their available inventory and options.”
https://twitter.com/itsartoir/status/1662902685463371777?s=46&t=A5S-z5IJslFoC5SVN0Jodg
4 Likes
Ukrainian minister of defence
https://twitter.com/oleksiireznikov/status/1662944820132708353?s=46&t=A5S-z5IJslFoC5SVN0Jodg
“Dear Australian friends,
Throughout history you have repeatedly proven that Australians are a nation of freedom-loving warriors who always stand up to a bully.
You are 15 thousand kilometers away, yet we are very close in our shared values and readiness to defend them.
That’s why during the first months of the russian aggression Australia was the largest contributor to Ukraine outside of NATO.
Your Bushmasters have been incredible in real combat operations.
But our fight for global freedom is not over yet and we still need your support. I encourage you today to join the international tank coalition for Ukraine.
In addition to tanks, we would be honored to receive the Australian Hawkies. They could prove invaluable to our troops during the counteroffensive.
Stand with Ukraine. Together we can defend our shared values.
Together, we can and we will achieve Victory.”
12 Likes
An article that has more of a ‘Russians are winning’ slant - to offset all the other stuff that is saying everything is looking good for Ukraine.
I’m not pushing an agenda - just worthwhile for balance purposes.
Home Europe Storm Shadow Disappoints, Ukraine’s Counter-Offensive Sputters As Russian Jets Decimate Zelensky’s Troops
Storm Shadow Disappoints, Ukraine’s Counter-Offensive Sputters As Russian Jets Decimate Zelensky’s Troops
By Vijainder K Thakur- May 27, 2023
Ukraine’s much-hyped counteroffensive appears to be sputtering, if not already dead, under relentless Russian pounding of Ukrainian weapons and ammunition stockpiles; and troop staging points.
Ukraine Secures ‘Deadly’ Sidewinder Missiles That Tore Apart Chinese MiG Fighters During Taiwan Conflict
For the counteroffensive to succeed, what is happening to Ukrainian forces should have been happening to Russian forces.
The Russian Aerospace Force (RuAF) has displayed good judgment and dexterity in the use of their resources – striking sprawling industrial facilities with Geran-2 kamikaze drones while using air/sea-launched low observable Kh-101 and Kalibr cruise missiles for pinpoint attacks.
When there is a need to punch hard, Russian forces strike with Onyx (BrahMos analog) supersonic missiles or Iskander-M quasi-ballistic missiles using land-based mobile launchers. All the while, Russian decoy drones force Ukrainian AD systems to wastefully expend their ammunition.
Missing The Kherson Magic
Ukraine’s counteroffensive should have started with fierce strikes against Russian logistics facilities, as was the case when Ukraine successfully forced Russian forces to retreat from the right side of the Dnieper River in the Kherson sector in the Autumn of 2022.
On that occasion, Ukrainian forces brilliantly used US-supplied HIMARS MLRS systems to choke Russian supply routes to an extent where it became untenable for Russia to continue supporting its forces on the right bank.
Unfortunately for Ukraine, following the withdrawal of Russian forces from the Dnieper right bank, the wily Russian military leadership reconfigured the deployment of their forces, storage depots, and Air Defence (AD) in a manner that greatly reduced the destructive potential of the 80 km range of HIMARS rockets.
Russia also tweaked its AD systems software to improve the kill rate of HIMARS rockets by its AD missiles. Slowly but surely, Russia neutralized the HIMARS advantage to a large extent.
Facilitating The Counteroffensive With Storm Shadow
Determined to weaken Russia through a proxy counteroffensive, on May 11, 2023, the UK threw caution to the wind and announced that it would gift Ukraine 250+ km range of Storm Shadow air-launched cruise missiles.
Defence Secretary Ben Wallace told Parliament that Britain is donating the Storm Shadow missiles to Ukraine to help it reclaim territory lost to Russia since the start of its invasion!
With the transfer of Storm Shadows, the UK blatantly crossed a Russian redline and became the first country to give Ukraine longer-range weapons capable of hitting targets deep inside Russia.
When Kyiv first used the Storm Shadow on May 12, 2023, the Ukrainian counteroffensive appeared imminent and ominous.
In an analysis posted on May 12, 2023, we analyzed the likely impact of introducing Storm Shadow missiles and concluded that Russia’s counter stealth radar network “is effective and will facilitate the interception of many Storm Shadow missiles.
“However, like HIMARS rockets and JDAM-ER bombs, some Storm Shadow missiles will get through Russian defenses. Considering the much greater reach of the Storm Shadow, its immunity to EW, and its more destructive warhead, every Storm Shadow that gets through will strike a painful blow.”
su-24
Su-24 with Storm Shadow Missile
Storm Turns Into A Shadow
Our analysis proved to be correct. Two weeks after the induction of Storm Shadow missiles, Ukraine has failed to degrade Russian ability to supply its forces, but some missiles have gotten through and struck painful blows, according to Ukrainian sources.
On May 12, 2023, two Storm Shadow missiles struck a Russian aviation school in Luhansk, killing nine airmen and destroying several aircraft.
On May 14, two Storm Shadow missiles targeted a Russian aviation school in Luhansk used by the Russian military.
On May 26, 2023, Storm Shadow missiles struck a Russian missile store in Mariupol, causing a massive explosion and fire.
In the same period, Russian Air Defence (AD) forces shot down Storm Shadow missiles as follows:
May 15
1
May 16
7
May 20
Unspecified number
May 22
Unspecified number
May 26
2
Russian AD forces have definitely played a key role in limiting the destructive potential of Storm Shadow missiles.
AD systems are normally countered through coordinated SEAD (Suppression of Enemy Air Defence) and attack missions or saturation strikes. Indeed, Ukraine’s opening Storm Shadow attack on May 12, 2023, in Luhansk was a well-executed SEAD & attack mission.
The most outstanding feature of the Luhansk strike was its technical sophistication and excellent coordination, indicative of a very high standard of training.
Ukraine reportedly used two Storm Shadow cruise missiles. The launch of the Storm Shadow missiles by a Ukrainian Su-24MR aircraft was evidently preceded by the launch of US-supplied ADM-160 decoy missiles, which forced Russian AD radars to light up prematurely and reveal their positions, only to be struck by AGM-88 HARM missiles launched by a Ukrainian MiG-29.
When the Storm Shadows came, Russian air defenses had gone dark!
The use of ADM-160 decoys was the first recorded in the conflict. The US had not announced the supply of the decoys to Ukraine, which was perhaps why Russian AD units were easily baited into engaging them.
Launch Platform Limitations
Besides Russian air defenses, Ukraine has not fully leveraged the potential of Storm Shadow missiles because of the limited number of Storm Shadow launch platforms in its inventory.
The Storm Shadow weighs 1,900 kg. Ukraine has two heavy fighters, Su-24 and Su-27, which are theoretically capable of carrying the missile.
At the start of the war in February 2022, Ukraine is speculated to have had 34 Su-27s and between 16-24 Su-24M in its inventory.
On May 2, Ukrainian Defense Minister Oleksii Reznikov, following his meeting with British Defense Secretary Ben Wallace, tweeted a composite image of a Su-24MR, with tail no 60, carrying a Storm Shadow missile on its right wing glove pylon.
The Su-24MR is a reconnaissance variant of the Su-24M. The number of Su-24MRs in Ukrainian inventory at the start of the war is speculated to be 10. It’s believed that 4 Su-24MRs have since been lost in the conflict.
Effectively, Reznikov revealed that Ukraine now has just 6 Storm Shadow launch platforms in service! The revelation wasn’t smart unless it was disinformation. However, a paucity of launch platforms could explain the limited use of Storm Shadow missiles in the run-up to the Ukrainian counteroffensive.
It was earlier speculated that Ukrainian Su-24M fighter-bombers were upgraded to carry Storm Shadow missiles in Poland starting in November 2022. Yes, six months before the UK officially announced its intent to transfer Storm Shadow missiles to Ukraine!
However, according to retired Deputy Commander of the People’s Militia of the DPR, Eduard Basurin, the aircraft with the tail number 60 did not leave the country for the upgrade to launch Storm Shadow missiles. This means UK military personnel upgraded the aircraft while based in Ukraine.
Ukrainian Air Force Sukhoi Su-24MR
Ukrainian Su-24 Losses
Interestingly, Russia claims to have shot down 3 Su-24 fighter bombers since the introduction of Storm Shadows – one each on May 13 (Lugansk), May 17 (near Varvarovka in DPR), and May 18 (Slavyansk).
The sudden surge in Ukrainian Su-24 shootdowns casts doubts about the sustainability of Ukrainian Storm Shadow operations. Clearly, the RuAF is vigorously hunting down Ukrainian Su-24s.
Conclusion
Ukraine’s failure to degrade Russia’s ability to keep its front-line troops well-fed and supplied through the use of Storm Shadow missiles is likely one of the most important reasons behind Ukraine’s inability to launch its counteroffensive, despite favorable weather conditions.
The limited number of Su-24MR in Ukrainian inventory and the absence of alternative long-range weapons in the supply pipeline, otherwise generously funded by the West, makes the prognosis for the Ukrainian counteroffensive rather grim.
Vijainder K Thakur is a retired IAF Jaguar pilot. He is also an author, software architect, entrepreneur, and military analyst. VIEWS PERSONAL
Follow the author @vkthakur
Previous article
China ‘Breathes Fire’ As Taiwan Set To Acquire US-Led NATO’s ‘Most Advanced’ Tactical Data Link System – Link 22
Next article
Stunning Stunts! Argentina’s Brand New Presidential Aircraft, ARG 01, Shocks Onlookers With Low-Pass Maneuvers
Vijainder K Thakur
Vijainder K Thakur is a retired IAF Jaguar pilot. He is also an author, software architect, entrepreneur, and military analyst. Reach out to the author at vkthakur (at) gmail.com
Exit mobile version
2 Likes
Interesting slant!
Statements like “Ukraine’s much-hyped counteroffensive appears to be sputtering, if not already dead” are quite laughable. Once I read that, the rest of the read has almost no credibility beyond that point.
7 Likes
Plenty of big bangs by the look of it.
Yeah agreed, still in training and receiving equipment so it’s unlikely to have started yet. At least they acknowledged how effective destroying logistics and supplies is.
However in a censored population in Russia, in the occupied territories, it could have a different reception, in addition to civilians in Ukraine worn down with attacks.
Propaganda war.
1 Like
It is interesting how different the Indian population view this conflict. There’s historical factors here that I think lead them to instinctively distrust Europe and the US, despite evidence. There’s a trend in some nations to believe Russian claims at face value.
Anyway, in this case I’ve seen zero evidence to support this guy’s assertion that Ukraine has lost all its equipment due to Russian bombing. The counteroffensive hasn’t failed, it just hasn’t started. We haven’t seen a single Leopard 2, Bradley, CV90, Marder or Stryker.
Ukraine has one shot at this and will launch when they feel they’ve got the largest chance of success. There’s substantial shaping operations, such as today’s missile strikes and the raids into Russia. (Multiple small raids continue to happen along the border). I think this guy is just impatient.
4 Likes
Bandung Conference of non-aligned nations, led by Nehru. It still has some relevance in the Global South.
And India has never forgotten when the US weaponised food and millions starved.
It’s only now with the Quads that India and the US are engaging in any sort of cooperation ( in part assisted by the western diversion of investment in manufacturing from China to India connected to de-risking economic dependence on China).
1 Like