It might end up coming down to who is available but you wouldn’t expect Roughead, Boyd, Redpath and Cloke to be in the same side
At this point Roughead is probably their number one choice for ruck, which leaves the other three as the key forward/backup ruckman. Cloke’s disadvantage is that he’s the worst ruck out of those three
West Coast would give them a run.
Cox and Glass might keep them ahead of the dogs but iirc they had Lynch, Hansen, Hunter and Seaby + couple of mid sized guys like Jones (Brett and Rowan) as well as Butler
Some of the Geelong sides weren’t much better
Geelong had one of the all time great backlines, King / Otten through the years, and a workmanlike forwardline.
West Coast had Dean Cox, Glass + (as much as he was a bell-end) Adam Hunter down back and a workmanlike forward line
Dogs have Dale Morris and… erm.