Season 2025 - West Coast

West Coast

Coach - Andrew McQualter

2024 –

Points For – 17th
Points Against – 16th

Top 5 Best and Fairest

  1. Jeremy McGovern
  2. Elliot Yeo
  3. Jake Waterman
  4. Liam Duggan
  5. Brady Hough

2024 Rising Star Noms

Harley Reid (Rnd 5)

Ins – Bo Allan, Liam Baker, Malakai Champion, Hamish Davis, Jack Graham, Lucas Greggo, Tom Gross, Matt Owies, Jobe Shanahan

Outs – Jordyn Baker, Tom Barrass, Coby Burgiel, Jai Culley, Jack Darling, Luke Edwards, Andrew Gaff, Jamaine Jones, Josh Rotham, Zane Trew, Alex Witherden

My Prediction

You have to have lived in Western Australia to truly understand what a pathetic group the West Coast fans are. They are like Collingwood fans with money. Very few things in life bring me more satisfaction that them becoming entirely irrelevant. They just don’t matter any more. They aren’t the worst list (although you could make that argument) and they are zero risk to play finals. They have topped up on experienced talent to replace those they lost. They are trash.

The backline reads average enough on paper, they lost Barrass but honestly if teams weren’t desperate for tall people who can catch a ball, he wouldn’t rate a mention. He wasn’t even the best back in this team. McGovern won a best and fairest last year which is nice for him but also a sign of how bad they are positioned. Ginbey should be playing this year should his bladder allow him. I think Baker probably plays off half back where I suspect he regrets his life choices within a fortnight. Hough was a positive last year and I think Maric is likely to play back. It’s a dumpster fire.

The midfield is just a test of Harley Reids shoulders. How long can he carry the team before Essendon pay overs to bring him home. Yeo was good in patches last year. Tim Kelly has again had good patches but he needs better mids to make him look better and I am not sure Jack Graham is that. I think Jayden Hunt will be used for speed in the middle but he is more average than the West Coast backline. It may be the worst midfield in the competition despite hosting a player who within a season or two will be the best player in the comp.

The forward line looked dangerous with Waterman playing 5 or 6 weeks of really high quality football before remembering that he was a spud. Oscar Allen threatens to be a top line player (if the people paid for their opinion in the media are right). Owies comes in to continue the theme of being bog average. Liam Ryan is exciting and for the four things he does per game looks great. They have the bones of a reasonable forward line that could perform well enough if they actually get enough ball (which they wont).

They have a little depth in the ruck with Matt Flynn and Bailey Williams both looking at the number one ruck spot. They may even play two rucks (something only the stupidest of teams attempts). The coach is high rated but then again, they all until they actually coach a team half full of VFL standard players and try and produce AFL results.

West Coast and their self entitled supporters have Essendon levels of patience and are not willing to accept a long rebuild, propping up their rubbish list with fill in players from other clubs (unfair to Baker) which will help them avoid that long term pesky rise up the ladder). They are still dreadful and will have a slight new coach bounce in the first half of the season before crashing and burning. They finish somewhere between 15 and 17. Long may they crash and burn.

13 Likes

There top 5 in the b&f reads like guys would prefer to see in 6-10th

I think Eagles will have a tough year, but i’m a little optimistic, feel they nailed the draft and Harley Reid will be their barometer again.

You likely expect to see a drop off from McGovern and Yeo this year.

Finish 13-16th

I liked all of Allan, Champion and Shanahan, Tom Gross may surprise big boy too.

Owies adds experience to forwardline
Jack Graham adds some depth
Liam Baker might help too, not sure where they will play him maybe half back given ball will be down there plenty still.

They will miss Barrass, and Darling, Gaff was pretty much cooked.

1 Like

There’s a lot of quality ranting in that summary…I love it.

Such lovely writing :grin:

4 Likes

Another bottom 2 finish looms. The guys they added I don’t think will move the needle too much. Big watch is on Reid. If he still hasn’t signed a contract extension by the mid-season bye this year, the scrutiny will intensify that he may want to come back to Victoria.

2 Likes

Lucky there is plenty of WA talent available this year

Fred Rodriguez (top 10 predicted mid)
Kody Curtin (Dans Brother KPD/KPF)

Charlie Banfield (father son)
Wesley Walley & Koby Evans (both Eagles NGA)

Hope Shanahan gets a crack in 2025.

Otherwise, meh. They’ll be better than Richmond and the home ground advantage may have them better in W/L than NM, but they aren’t going to be much more I don’t think.

13-15 for mine, which technically has them in my 6-16 bracket, but very confident they’ll be lower end.

2 Likes

image

Shanahan will likely have to wait until injury as behind Allen and Waterman and then resting ruck Williams etc.

Backline looks a bit more vulnerable without Barrass

die

that best 23 will get them 1 maybe 2 wins.
the home ground advantage will get them 4-5 wins.
didn’t know they had 2 williamses.

They lost a fair bit of their home ground advantage when Dean Margetts retired.

9 Likes

good start to the year

I doubt he’s the first bloke to do that at a festival.
not a good start from the lad, also not giving his details to police, learning from the Benny cousins play book.

2 Likes

Owies will struggle mightily as won’t have the easy picking scraps off Curnow and McKay. Graham and Baker, in particular, add some class, which will be needed, as the WEagles list looks thin for talent.

They had 11 players depart last year, that is not turning over or refreshing, it is Caaarlton like in terms of gutting your list. Bottom 4 for mine, home ground advantage or not.

1 Like

They’ll improve 6 or 7 wins and will be ahead of the likes of Richmond and Gorth.

1 Like

lol people taking a ■■■■ at a music festival should be the least of worries for police compared to what else goes on

2 Likes

I think theyll finish below gorth

1 Like

Bottom 4

Bottom 4 but will rebuild and win a premiership before we even win a elimination final

3 Likes

Maybe the gags about fat Harley weren’t just optical illusions

Harley doesnt need to win the time trial to get a spot.
He’s first pencilled in, Ginbey on the other hand needs to put his best foot forward after his festival.