21 MAR 2017 - 12:05AM
One slice of some 'healthy' breads contains more salt than a packet of chips: study
A new study has revealed some surprises in the levels of salt in the bread products eaten by millions of Australians.
By Alyssa Braithwaite
A sandwich is seen as a healthy lunch choice for many Australians, but those two slices of bread could contain more salt than a packet of chips, a new study has found.
Researchers from The George Institute for Global Health analysed 1439 bread products from 2010 to 2017, including loaves, rolls, crumpets, bagels, English muffins and flat breads, and found that some loaves of bread contain more than a third of the daily recommended salt intake in just two slices.
Rye breads were found to contain on average 20 per cent more salt that targets set by the Australian Food and Health Dialogue (FHD), which recommended sodium in bread products to be reduced to 400 milligrams per 100 grams. The FHD is a project involving representatives of government, the health sector and the manufacturing industry, set up to create action plans and set targets for reducing consumption of risk-associated nutrients including saturated fat and sugar and salt, and increasing consumption of fruits, vegetables and whole grain foods
The George Institute study found flat bread such as wraps, naan, roti and tortillas also included "unnecessary high levels of salt", on average containing a third more salt than white bread.
The study revealed the loaves with the highest salt levels were Schwob's Dark Rye, with just once slice containing more than double the amount of salt as a serving of Kettles sea salt crisps (an average serving contains 0.55g of salt per 45g serving).
Artisan baker Bowan Island's Wholemeal Sourdough also registered a high salt content (1.6g salt/100g), almost three time saltier than the lowest-salt option - Bill's Certified Organic 100% Wholemeal Sourdough (0.6g salt/100g).
The study found that in general, leading bread manufacturers have decreased the level of salt in their bread product, including Coles ( from 501 to 398 mg/100 g), Aldi (464 to 386 mg/100 g), Woolworths (430 to 390 mg/100 g), George Weston (470-388 mg/100 g), Goodman Fielder (463-411 mg/100 g) and MEB foods (361-271 mg/100 g). However, it said this wasn't an across-the-board result, with the salt content increasing in the products of some brans, such as Mountain Bread Company (333 to 432 mg/100 g - up 30 per cent), Old Time Bakery (110 to 294 mg/100 g; up 167 per cent) and Freedom Foods (535 to 584 mg/100g; up 9 per cent).
While the study showed salt levels in bread have generally decreased by about 10 per cent in seven years, lead author Clare Farrand said too many commonly eaten products still contain excessive amounts of salt.
"There has been a clear and welcome drop in salt levels in bread, particularly in those products that were covered by the salt reduction targets. However, some breads still contain high levels of salt," Farrand said.
"We know that excess salt in our diet increases blood pressure and the risk of stroke and cardiovascular disease, so our findings are incredibly worrying - especially as many of the products that have the highest levels of salt are perceived by families as being the healthiest."
The results have been released to mark the 10th World Salt Awareness Week (March 20-26), organised by World Action on Salt & Health. The theme for 2017 is 'Salt: The Forgotten Killer'.
The average Australian adult eats around 8-10 grams of salt every day - almost double the World Health Organisation recommendation of less than 5 grams per day.
Processed and packaged foods account for around 75 per cent of salt in the diet of Australians.
Associate Professor Karen Charlton, a public health nutritionist from the University of Wollongong, says the results are actually quite good news for many Australians.
"The average salt reduction in average bread and rolls has been 10 per cent, so that's a move in the right direction, so I actually think that's a good thing," Charlton tells SBS.
"For most of the bread and rolls that are produced by the major manufacturers, such as Coles, Aldi, Woolworths, George Weston and so on, those have all reduced their salt content of their bread products, and I would suggest that those producers contribute the most to sales of bread.
"This analysis looks at sodium content of bread and flat breads, but it doesn't actually look at the proportion of sales of those products. So for example, if 80 per cent of the population are eating those breads from the major manufacturers and those breads comply, then we don't necessarily have a major problem with those few consumers who are buying the more boutique-style breads that seem to be higher in sodium."
In Australia, there are no mandatory salt targets for food manufacturers, just the voluntary targets set out in the FHD.
Charlton says she would like to see mandatory salt targets introduced in Australia, as they have been in countries like South Africa and Argentina, as well as clearer labeling of salt content on products.
"What I think the data is saying is really compare when you're at the supermarket like for like, and don't assume one brand is necessarily similar across all of its product range," Charlton says.
"In lots of school lunch boxes, parents give a sandwich thinking that's the healthy option, which it generally is, but keep a look out [for the salt content].
"The message mustn't be 'avoid bread', because bread is a staple and it provides fibre, and it also provides folic acid and iodine, which has to be added to the salt used in bread, by law, so particularly for children bread actually provides a fair amount of iodine that they require each day."
The 5 highest-salt sliced breads 2017:
Schwob's Dark Rye: 1.7g of salt per 100g, or 1.2g per 70g slice
Bowen Island Artisan Breads Wholemeal Sourdough: 1.6g of salt per 100g, or 0.7g per 45g serving
Schwob's White Sourdough: 1.6g of salt per 100g, or 1.1g per 70g slice
Schwob's Swiss Farmers Light Rye: 1.6g of salt per 100g, or 1.1g per 70g slice
Schwob's Swiss Bakery Multigrain: 1.6g of salt per 100g, or 1.1g per 70g slice
The 5 lowest-salt sliced breads 2017:
Bill's Certified Organic 100% Wholemeal Sourdough: 0.6g of salt per 100g, or 0.2 grams per 40g serving
Bill's Certified Organic Medium Rye Sourdough: 0.6g of salt per 100g, or 0.2 grams per 40g serving
Bill's Certified Organic Ancient Grains + Activated Super Seeds Sourdough: 0.6g of salt per 100g, or 0.2 grams per 40g serving
Bill's Organic Multigrain Sourdough: 0.6g of salt per 100g, or 0.2 grams per 40g serving
Bill's Certified Organic 7 Seeds Multigrain Sourdough: 0.6g of salt per 100g, or 0.2 grams per 40g serving
5 highest-salt flat breads 2017:
Mission Chapattis Garlic: 2.3g of salt per 100g, or 1.1 grams per 46g serving
Mission Wraps Zesty Garlic Herb: 2.3g of salt per 100g, or 1.6g per 71g serving
Coles Tortillas: 2.3g of salt per 100g, or 0.9g per 40g serving
Mission Wraps Lite Super Soft: 2.3g of salt per 100g, or 1.6g per 71g serving
Mission Wraps Whole Grain: 2.3g of salt per 100g, or 1.6g per 71g serving
5 lowest-salt flat breads 2017:
Mission White Corn Tortillas: 0.1g of salt per 100g, or 0.0g per 26g serving
Old Time Bakery Wholesome Gluten Free Wraps: 0.1g of salt per 100g, or 0.1 per 62.5g serving
Vitastic Sorj Healthy Soft Wraps Rye: 0.3g of salt per 100g, or 0.1 per 38g serving
Vitastic Sorj Healthy Soft Wraps Wholemeal: 0.5g of salt per 100g, or 0.2g per 38g serving
MEB Pita Bread Wholemeal: 0.5g of salt per 100g, or 0.4g per 80g serving
All of the study information on salt in bread and bread products is now included in the George Institute's FoodSwitch app.