Speculation on the team to pile on the Cats - 2020 round 16

Two separate statements:

  1. I don’t think we can win all three remaining games.
  2. We can still make the 8 with two wins.

I reckon tank this one then load up v Port.

1 Like

Don’t think so. Plenty of rookies only get 1 year.

I think behind closed doors they’d know if he’s coming back next season. I suspect he isn’t.

If he’s not, don’t play him (as bad as Gleeson and Guelfi are)

1 Like

Theoretically yes, but that’d be a hugely ballsy call, given the impending list shrinkages.

And he’d be just as far back in the queue at either of those club.

If he did knock back a contract, you’d have to assume he already had a handshake agreement with someone else.

We didn’t rest Joe against WC, now we have to.
Our forward line will now be compromised because Hooker HAS to play on Hawkins.
Don’t destroy BZT’s confidence by playing him on a monster forward.
It won’t end well.

Hurls can take Rohan.
SMACK has to come in…sorry
What if he pulled a 4 goal performance out of his ar*e to sink the Cats ?
That would be sweet.

Redman has more upside than Gleeson.
Make that switch now and stick to it.

McKenna farewell game (if we know it’s happening).

Too young against Geelong’s forward line, there experience alone will destroy us.
Need Hooker or Hurley back, just for talk, help set people up, so on.

That is the attitude that has held the club back for 10 years.
Start Hooker forward, can always move him back.
Back in BZT, Ridley and Francis to get the job done.

2 Likes

That’s the line up that got up smashed by Goldcoast. who’s best forward is a 1st/2nd year player (King)
not Tom (current best forward in the game) Hawkins.

Gleeson and Guelfi

Guelfi is not a defender
Gleeson is not a “small”

They are not bad, they are being used for jobs that totally dont suit

I’m kinda on the fence with this call.

7 Likes

Having a unit like Hooker in defense might make them walk a little taller. Don’t think I want to see Hawkins ragdolling Zerk this early in his career

Oh he’s good to go alright

5 Likes

McKenna is a no brainer for either of these 2 players.
Good defender, with massive rebound ability, but don’t play him if he is leaving the club.
All 3 of them have brain fades. None of them come close to Saad who is among our top 5-6 players

Done a few ladder predictors and we’ve won the flag in a few of them so I think we can still make the 8.

13 Likes

Gleeson was proposed as a winger, 4 years ago. He is looking even more like a winger now. But when he was tried on a wing in a couple of games, he was disappointing.

It’s a good opportunity for us to play all of our injured players and see if we can ■■■■ up next year as well.

1 Like

Statistically it is possible for us to win the flag.

Hawking reckoned objects can escape black holes.
I don’t see it happening.

1 Like

Yeah we wouldn’t want hawkins in the commentry team showing how he kicked a few on a young Zerk-thatcher during his 200th game celebrations.

2 Likes

I like your positivity.
need like every result to fall our way and to win every remaining game.

then to top it off and win the flag would be a Bradbury.
Hope McGrath gets back for the grand final.

4 Likes

Did JB really do that?

If so what a flog. And i really liked him as a player.

His body is in Maroochydore, his mind is in a pub in Eglish, Dungannon