Tac/u18 Thread

So is Smith an inside or outside mid?

Both

Loved that highlights package of Collier-Dawkins. Possibly even more than the Smith video. He has a very similar style to Bontempeli, and doesnt look like he needs to many touches to damage the opposition. I think I like the idea of his size in our midfield more than a 6 footer like Smith.

That’s my line of thought as well, in 2-3 years R C-D would compliment our midfield better with his combination of size, speed and skill. And in the meantime he’d be able to play forward, back and on the outside.

1 Like

RCD’s main query is his ability to find the ball on transition. You see players like Bont and Cripps and despite their work on the inside they also manage to find the ball on linkup play to improve their numbers which RCD lacks at this stage.

Walsh and Smith find so much of the ball due to their footy smarts and workrate when without the ball and RCD doesn’t quite have that but that’s not to say he is lazy either since I’ve seen him do some great chase down tackles aswell.

If a club can work on his outside game/running then you have the makings of a player that could be better than both Cripps and Bont because he has them both covered for speed and foot skills and he might even grow taller than 193cm that he is now since he was 187cm at the end of last year.

3 Likes

Sounds like the issues Dangerfield had early on, you’d think as far as chinks go it’d be one of the easier one to amend; especially considering his speed/skill combo

1 Like

If i remember correctly Cripps was seen as only an inside stoppage specialist in his draft year. The query was on his ability to round out his game. Bont was a bolter who had major upside.

Id be more than happy with RCD based on his output to date and upside when in an AFL system. But something tells me that he will end up in the top 5.

Serious question. Who would you prefer for us out of RCD and Hately?

1 Like

I would take RCD purley because I feel he has a better contested side. Hately is closer to a Pendlebury/Heppell type and his kicking is similar to Heppell. Collier-Dawkins is one of the better kicks in the draft

2 Likes

:grimacing:

1 Like

I think he’ll go to the Bulldogs.

SOLD. Fully invested now.

Damn.

Better contested and kick?

BRING HIM IN

As the year is going on and I’m getting a better understanding of this years draft crop I’m not as worried about where we finish on the ladder.

After about pick 6 it’s very close with about 10 or so players in and around the 7-15 range that I couldn’t flat out prefer over the other. So say we finish 9-10 and end up with pick 9 or 10 which could also become lower with compensation picks it shouldn’t massively effect us with quality’s of player available if we finished 11-13 which at this rate I don’t think we will anyway.

You have in that 7-15 range and even further as midfidlers
Riley Collier-Dawkins
Jackson Hately
Jye Caldwell
Xavier Duursma

And players with midfield potentional
Connor Rozee
Curtis Taylor

And players that could bolt or even go in the 20s around our 2nd pick such as

Chayce Jones
James Rowbottom
Jack Bytel
Tom Berry
Tom Lewis
Luke Valente
Xavier O’Halloran

So that’s 13 players I’d be rapt taking at either our first or second, 2 of those players mentioned are 180cm but Lewis is as pure an inside mid as you could see in the Viney mould and Jones can play taller and players the game a lot like Guelfi but I’d say he has more weapons.

2 Likes

Our second pick is actually GWS’s. So Cameron getting suspended may be a huge blessing for us!

8 Likes

A player for WA playing tomorrow has the last name Smallwood, how unfortunate

1 Like

Was just going to mention this. We should be finishing above them now, hence our second rounder that we sent to GC for Saad should now theoretically be upgraded.

It will be great if we can say we traded a 1st, 2nd and 3rd round picks for SSS and a pick upgrade!

1 Like

Fox Footy from 2.10 today

Inside mid Ely Smith was a late call up today for Country and he finished with 32 disposals and 10 clearances, one to watch as a potential bolter