Oh, don’t get me wrong - so do I. It’s just that it’s a rung below Superunknown and Badmotorfinger. It was the first time they sounded a bit… I dunno… “tired” in parts, and some of the songs seemed a bit underdone.
It was 1996, grunge didn’t know what to do with itself.
I like this album more than, say, No Code which is from the same year. (Azza may not like that view!) Although Tiny Music is the best album of that lot that came out that year
I remember eagerly awaiting the follow-up to Superunknown and then finally Pretty Noose dropped on radio. My immediate reaction was “oh”. It wasn’t bad - not by a long chalk (in fact, these days it’s held up quite well) - it just didn’t wow me, in the same way things like Outshined, Rusty Cage, Spoonman and Black Hole Sun did. This song, however, very much DID…
Well that’s the thing about music, or any art form. Things speak to different people for different reasons and you like what you like. Everyones opinion is valid.