Trade Discussion 2018 thread #1 - We’re gonna need a bigger boat for the wave pool!

I love how someone can straight-faced justify their source as “the vibe” because they got it real early.

1 Like

I’m sure a Tasmanian hawks bandwagoner has all the intimate details of his clubs acquiral of GWS midfielder Dylan Shiel.

11 Likes

Given our struggles on the MCG this year, the idea of adding two of the games best runners who also have the ability to hit targets isn’t exactly a craziest idea.

Scully also comes cheaper than Shiel in both contract and trade value, only concern would be his medical.

Don’t forget what happened the last time we picked up a hardworking outisde player from the Giants.

Is he any good at building car ports.

2 Likes

I’m not saying I don’t have reservation about his durability or age, But to suggest he hasn’t become an excellent footballer is naive and/or blinkered.

At the right price, he’d be an excellent acquisition.

2 Likes

He did, but is it a surprise that at 26-28 he hit his peak? Similar to what Melksham is doing at Melbourne now.

Question is will he continue that form to 32.

What and who you know has not a lot to do with where you live.
I can recall quite a bit of good Essendon inf coming here from Tassie.

2 Likes

There used to be a guy running a cafe down outside Hobart who knew a fair bit.

Not sure what happened to him. Ordinary bloke though.

4 Likes

The second set of ears probably help

14 Likes

Yep. Very much a question of whether his body allows him to continue to play at the level of the last few years. That’s the risk.

1 Like

Sorry, that was meant to poke fun of confident Hawks supporters and their sources.

Please send through a list of acceptable trade discussion topics and I’ll try and adhere to it :roll_eyes:.

2 Likes

Yeh
coming from Reboot when he lived in Hobart :slight_smile:

When the pigeons actually made it across Bass Strait. :smile:

2 Likes

Nah Scully is the better of the two. But they both tend to butcher the footy. Maybe that’s why Coniglio, Hopper, Taranto etc are not rumoured to be going anywhere

Boot fled tassie after tippa went to his cafe and told him to GET FKD

9 Likes

Are you Adam McPhee?

1 Like

ANNOUNCE A. BENTICK

5 Likes

Will a mushroom do?

1 Like

He got a mention in the paper today for being part of the EDFL premiers team.

Alex McLeod at St Bernards and Courtney Johns retiring as a winner also got a run.

2 Likes

We WILL get yolman and we WILL NOT LIKE IT

4 Likes