Trade Talk 2019 Pt2

Yeah, but the number of “live” players available at our pick doesn’t change unless someone opts to not match a bid, doesn’t it?

Eg - Green is bid on at pick 3. Gws match it with #6 , Melbourne “drop” to pick 4 but they still get the same player they could have named at 3. Sydney have dropped from 5 to 6 but the field of players available is exactly the same.

Or in the articles example, Henry notionally gets taken using 15 and part of 20, but those two picks were originally going to be gold coast selected players anyway, plus they get whoever they take with 10. The total number of players taken before our first pick doesn’t alter (if we assume that in reality we don’t have access to other clubs academy players). The only real impact is that our picks shuffle down slightly and become worth less fairy dust points? I think? My brain hurts.

Edit:. Unless a bid comes on a player that wipes out two full picks above ours, in which case we go up the order somewhat. But I don’t think there’s any player/club candidates for that this year.

5 Likes

ok lets just say Swans bid on Greene at 5
GWS match bid, but first offer
GWS trade pick 6 & 80 (1751points) to Geelong for 14 & 24 1946 points

pick 5 = 1878 x 20% =375
Giants need 1503 points

so would lose 14, 24 and get pick 39 back.
If the Giants didnt do the trade they would lose 6 and receive pick 52

in that instance its better that GWS use 2 picks before our pick to match the bid.

But if Port trade pick 29, 66 (733 points) to Brisbane for 34 & 52 (788 points)

then we go back in the order as Port use pick 34 to match mead bid which is after our pick.

same could happen with Hawks if they trade pick 30 for later picks to another club to match maginess bid. and it shuffles us back.

So how do we exchange our 2 picks in the 30’s for 1 pick in the 20’s & 2 picks in the 40’s ???

Thus turning 2 draft picks into 3.

only clubs could do would be Lions or Crows.

21, 42, 52 Lions 1426 points
23, 45, 49 Crows 1449 points
28, 45, 49 crows 1311 points
31,33, 61 1304 points

Would prefer to just trade
31, 61 741 points ess
29, 66 733 points Port

1 Like

If I’m Port, I take 29 & 66 over 31 & 61.

Unless they are sure someone they’re really interested in in the 60s has another suitor who’s ahead of them.

They will lose 29 for Mead who is a father son.
All depends on where he is bidded at.

Right, I thought I had read somewhere only 1 F/S expected in the first two rounds.

Hawks have McGuiness (pick 16 in cal twomey phantom) (they have picks 11, 30
Port have Mead (19 in cal twomey phantom)
Freo have Henry (15 in Twomey phantom)
Tom Green Academy pick 5 twomey phantom

Port Adelaide father-son Jackson Mead could get past the Power’s pick 29, which would be the ideal result for the club.

This hurts my head every time I hear about these points, live trades etc

3 Likes

Actual image of every Blitz user in this thread

1 Like

So Martin is asking for $1m a year for 5 years?! Yikes.

Edit- actually $3m over 5 years, $1m for his first year.

fark me, this guy is going to make out like a bandit considering hes painfully mediocre

Just pricing himself to get through to FCFC

Well that or play for gold coast or Melbourne…

Its a damn shame we couldn’t have gotten him along with Shiel the year before.

Henry is the next Walters

Will be the best player of the draft. He’s a fkn gun

1 Like

Thats a big call.
would you rate Walters the best player form his draft?

1 Jack Watts Sandringham Dragons TAC Cup Melbourne
1 2 Nic Naitanui Swan Districts WAFL West Coast
1 3 Stephen Hill West Perth WAFL Fremantle
1 4 Hamish Hartlett West Adelaide SANFL Port Adelaide
1 5 Michael Hurley Northern Knights TAC Cup Essendon
1 6 Chris Yarran Swan Districts WAFL Carlton
1 7 Daniel Rich Subiaco WAFL Brisbane Lions
1 8 Ty Vickery Sandringham Dragons TAC Cup Richmond
1 9 Jack Ziebell Murray Bushrangers TAC Cup North Melbourne
1 10 Phil Davis North Adelaide SANFL Adelaide

Geez 2008 was a bust from the early picks
Hurley probably best of the top 10 given Natanuis injuries.

Sidebotom, Shuey, Beams, Hanneberry, Zaka, Zieball, Davis

Yeh walters would probably be in the conversation.

Re do the 2008 draft
5 Sidebottom
23 Beams
55 Tom Rockliff
58 Luke Breust
67 Ricky Henderson

PSD 3 Ben Cousins

Rookie
5 J Garlett
21 Jarryd Blair
36 Matt Suckling
50 Sam Jacobs
64 Greg Broughton

I didn’t mention anything about Walters being the best player of his draft. I think Henry will be the pick of this draft though

Hopefully Freo are made to pay dearly then.

If anyone’s wondering…

because fark you, that’s why.

Behind Ty Vickery for starters .