Trade talk - from September 2025 (Part 8)

I’m not getting my hopes up re Flanders. Saint fans seem to think he’s already agreed to go to them.

Yeah sounds like it.

1 Like

I’d be more than happy to play Merrett in the VFL next year than trade him to Hawthorn for Pick 8.

I still believe some, even many, of Clubs in the window will make a play for him, Collingwood have already been mentioned, if Saints miss Flanders, I wouldn’t be surprised if they had a look. Even the interstate Clubs might have a crack and I haven’t even got to Geelong.

As for Hawthorn screwing us around, who cares, we’ve been doing to ourselves for 20 years.

5 Likes

One bad game for a bloke who is 33 next year. Cameron aint gonna get better. Not playing for a year means squat. They will already be making moves to get him.

Cost too much, JUH will be cheap.

And Neale was ■■■■■ in the GF. Wait for the JUH to cats stories, not far away.

I just quoted what was on the AFL website

1 Like

Must not be up to date, or an old article. I found one from trade period last year so im guessing it’s that because the wording is the same.

You can trade picks from 2025, 2026 and 2027 now.

2 Likes

BS

He’ll get smashed with soft tissue injuries next year, Gunston wont do that again and they’ll finish near us.

Take anything we can get to say #BYEZACH

3 Likes

Hawthorn did almost miss out on the 8. They’re a few key injuries away from finishing in the bottom half.

5 Likes

Bottom Fourthorn inc

2 Likes

I don’t agree. I think they’re a very good side, but no better than the top 5 or so.

If they’re better than Geelong & co., what happened the first week of the finals? They only just prevailed over Collingwood. And they finished 3rd on the ladder after H&A, 2pts clear of Collingwood, GWS and Freo.

1 Like

And had 73 goals contributed by a 35yo. I think they’re going far too early for a Merrett top-up style trade and would be a glorious death ride next year.

2 Likes

You’ll get pick 8 for him next year, why do that this year?

2 Likes

Things are never as good or as bad as you think is one of the best sayings in football. I remember watching Melbourne win their flag and thinking they had a great side. Better than Richmond’s recent premiership sides, I’ve no doubt there is a lot of luck in football.

3 Likes

You trot this line out all the time. What a load a bullshit.

6 Likes

I think it’s true for many.

On here it’s a different story but I don’t think we anywhere near represent most supporters.

You only have to look at how many people were stoked at the SSS trades or the Shiel trade full well knowing that we were throwing away our future to never be more than a 8th-12th placed side.

Even now there are plenty of fans who don’t want to see us bottom out, who don’t want to face a rebuild and would rather keep Draper, Merrett etc for another 12th placed finish rather than hit the bottom.

I actually don’t understand why some people hate the thought of winning a spoon

8 Likes

Not sure about that.

Because we are too good for a spoon apparently.

we need to bottom out. Now’s the perfect time.

Time to actually be patient for once because at this point I would rather sit through a rebuild over the club blowing smoke up my ass for the 20th year in a row

winning a spoon is probably more difficult than winning a premiership. Look at the competition the last 5 years.

2 Likes