Trade talk - from September 2025 (Part 8)

Please give WC band 2 for Allen

We nearly beat them with our VFL team.

12 Likes

They’ll actually have a free look as some recycled dudes the Eagles. 4 extra rookie spots is helpful, just look at our mid season draft haul thanks to the injuries.

Finn Macrae looks likely to be one. See if they can hit a few. Just need them to jump up the ladder so we can ask for our assistance package haha

And the assistance package should be allowance to pay out a few contracted players outside of the salary cap to refresh faster. Kinda like the amnesty clause in the NBA ages ago

Hall yes but the rest havent shown enough imo. Theyre kids but will they be regular 23 players?

Wilson yes. Definitely.

Steele/Macrae out and Garcia/Boxshall in. They’re the next crop coming through.

1 Like

You seem to have this peculiar way about you to cherry pick outcomes that ferment your sense of hopelessness and refuse to acknowledge anything happening at the club that may in fact be genuinely positive.
e.g skipper wants out- on face value can be construed as a poor result for Essendon Football Club. But of course you won’t run with the other side of the ledger which we all know will be a minimum of 2 first rounders if Hawthorn are serious.
Noobermensch the draft guru is licking his chops at draft opportunity, and even old Aceboy has turned the corner.
Meanwhile, you’re stuck in the doldrums of misery.

8 Likes

Boxshall I like, don’t get the Owen’s hype. You’ve included our biggest duds from our young crop lol. There’s a few of those on the Saints list as well.

Collard is their biggest dud I think.

One of.

I like Hastie, I like Arie too.

I’ve literally listed our youngish types playing vs their younger types playing…

Since Zach re-signed he has won 4 of 5 Crichtons. I hate the way this has played out damaging for all. Im Just not buoyed by losing our best player for two mid to late range first rd picks that may or may not be afl players.

yes the captain has a role to play and I don’t like the way it’s gone down, but when are we going to hold the club to Account in terms of what is going on?

high performance changes great, why did it take so long?

6 Likes

Our picks after the Allen Compo trade to GC like this:

Get pick 61 (which will come in to around 51 after the bids absorb heaps of mid range picks) as something to help match on Sweid.

Trade another future 3 for pick 45 or something as well.

2 Likes

Conveniently missed a few though.
A bloke that came 2nd in our BnF for a start.

Our list clearly needs more young talent though. Hopefully the club wakes up and moves Merrett on to help with this.

So that’s something to be optimistic about, but you’d rather not be?

6 Likes

I don’t think your break was long enough. We have a good young contingent of young players and are clearing out the snakes. Onward and upward, let’s keep going.

1 Like

The time taken to make change has cost us players.

1 Like

Surely you can’t be asking this with a straight face?
Are you trying to pretend the majority on here haven’t been doing this?

GC would get better offers points wise than that. Plus I think they’ll likely have to use 7 for Petracca

There you go, positive change at the club and likely to deliver a great outcome for the club.
Welsh has taken charge and quite conceivably allay any concerns you have about inertia

Yeah I was going for like for likes.

Didn’t mention Tauru or Phillipou either, or NWM.

We’ve got a good younger fleet coming through. Is that age bracket above that lacks

We aren’t even AFL worthy the hole we are in sadly, off field we are a absolute joke of a club complete embarrassment.

On field we don’t have any stars within our club, sure we are rebuilding, well our President doesn’t think so, more BS delusion coming out of Essendon.

2 Likes

100% agreed. And also remember, with Zach we are giving Hawthorn the missing piece to a chance at a dynasty era given their age profile.

I’d rather we just burn to the ground than trade in spuds and watch them turn Merrett into a premiership player..

3 Likes