If I’m GWS…and I think I can only afford to keep 2 out of Kelly/Coniglio/Shiel beyond 2019…then I would be organising extensions NOW on the 2 that I think I can retain. Make the offers lucrative.
I just can’t see them letting one go, without trying very hard to lock the other two in.
Otherwise their midfield could be gutted in the space of twelve months.
I knew trade talk had well and truly started when we talk about offering the likes of Hartley to a top 4 side. Then I remembered D Buckley and thought perhaps it’s not so ridiculous.
Kind of different circumstance that one. Yes he supported Geelong but primarily he only want to move back to the surf coast so he was hardly going to play for anyone in Melbourne. It was as much about moving home to the lifestyle he wanted, not specifically to play for Geelong.
True. I didn’t think he was good enough but it shows how important some players become given a set of circumstances and being able to then produce. Once Joe went down, he became quite important. I reckon we beat Hawks if we had him instead of Brown as our focal point.
Nankervis was a reasonable footballer but changes clubs and becomes arguably the most important player in the best side in the comp that also has Dusty, Cotch, Jack and Rance.